What can be done to stop rampant corruption in government?

We hope that corruption will one day be a thing of the distant past.

The government must have the political will to reform the parliamentary and state legislature systems and separate them from the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister’s Department, WH Cheng writes.

On 1 October, the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) celebrated its 53rd anniversary with a remark from chief commissioner Azam Baki that corruption within the government has been getting rampant despite all its efforts to combat corrupt practices nationwide.

Yes, MACC has gone all out in its efforts to get rid of this scourge from the public sector ever since, with activities such as education, training, awareness and all sorts of other programmes to educate and make civil servants aware of the circumstances, penalties, fines and blacklisting.

However, none of these efforts seems to have be effective despite the MACC going all out. Instead, more and more civil servants are indulging in corrupt practices as a way of earning some lucrative income to finance their luxurious lifestyles.

First of all, why do these civil servants continue their corrupt practices. Worst of all, even many newly recruited civil servants have learned how to become corrupt instead of enhancing their productivity? Are all these due to culture, a very normal kind of practice these civil servants have been practicing for decades, from generation to generation, creating and enhancing connections?

Despite MACC going nationwide to educate and raise awareness among these civil servants on the dangers and of how bad it is being a corrupt official, corruption remains rampant in the government sector till today, and it is  becoming worse as the years goes by.

Many corrupt government officials have been investigated, caught, arrested, charged in court, sentenced to imprisonment for many years. Yet, more and more government officials are indulging in corrupt practices, and no one in the MACC knows exactly why this is happening despite all its efforts. These MACC officials and their team seem to be frustrated.

READ MORE:  Police chief’s revelations: Bar supports establishment of royal commission of inquiry

One notable senior politician from the previous ruling party who is now attach to the current ruling coalition today, once said: “We hired you to combat corruption, arrest these guys and put them in jail. That is why you are here today and do not complain or show your frustration. Just do your job and that’s it!”

From this comment uttered by the senior politician, what can you conclude from the way he told off the then-MACC official?

It means in combating corruption, strong political will is required. It must start from the top, those who are sitting up there – the prime minister, the cabinet ministers, members of Parliament, chief ministers, menteris besar, state executive councillors, state legislative assembly members, city mayors and presidents of municipal and district councils, the government chief secretary, secretary-generals of ministry, director generals, divisional heads, department heads – right down to the bottom.

The stumbling block to the efforts to combat corruption today lies with the Prime Minister’s Department, which has for decades fully controlled the many kinds of agencies as well as Parliament. Even the Speaker of Dewan Rakyat or the House of Representatives and the President of Dewan Negara (Senate) both report to the minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (in charge of law and parliamentary affairs).

So the country’s highest law-making institution is not even an independent body itself to effectively play its role in providing checks and balances on the current government in its regular proceedings, transactions, policy implementation, projects, tenders, procurements and budgetary expenditure.

READ MORE:  Royal commission of inquiry, IPCMC a must now following police chief’s revelation

And why is Parliament still under the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister’s Department? If this continues, then the Dewan Rakyat Speaker and the Dewan Negara President will forever have no freedom to exercise their powers and roles to ensure MPs and senators carry out checks on the government in the most effective way as it was supposed to be.

Just look at all those parliamentary special select committees which were appointed by the previous Speaker to oversee the portfolios of various ministries:

  • Consideration Special Select Committee
  • Budget Special Select Committee
  • Defence and Home Affairs Special Select Committee
  • Gender Equality and Family Development Special Select Committee
  • States and Federal Relations Special Select Committee
  • Major Public Appointments Special Select Committee
  • Elections Special Select Committee
  • Human Rights and Constitutional Affairs Special Select Committee
  • International Relations and Trades Special Select Committee
  • Science, Innovation And Environment Special Select Committee
  • and of course the Public Accounts Committee (PAC)

So, why are all these parliamentary select committees not living up to their oversight roles and responsibilities? It is because the Speaker needs to authorise these select committees and empower them to carry out their checks-and- balances role. In doing so, the Speaker needs to obtain the permission or approval from the minister in the Prime Minister’s Department before he can issue the authorisation.

This shows that Parliament itself is not the independent institution it is supposed to be because its administration and management falls right under the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister’s Department.

Parliament was once an independent institution governed under the Parliamentary Services Act 1963, but this Act was abolished in 1992, and control of the institution then fell under the Prime Minister’s Department.

READ MORE:  Tengku Adnan RM1m corruption case: We need answers!

The MACC itself is also under the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister’s Department with the appointment of the MACC chief commissioner being determined by the prime minister himself – though, in name, the appointment is ceremoniously made by the Yang Di-Pertuan Agong after the PM approves the candidate first. So, is the MACC really independent?

So what can be done to stop the rampant corruption in the government? Nothing – unless there is a clear political will by the sitting government to change and reform the parliamentary and state legislature systems and separate them from the jurisdiction of the Prime Minister’s Department and the various menteris besar/chief ministers’ departments of the various states. (The state legislative assemblies are also currently controlled by the respective menteris besar/chief minsters’ departments.)

If such reforms are carried out from federal to state levels, all legislative bodies would be independent of the executive. Only then would these legislatures (parliament and state legislative assemblies) be able to provide checks and balances on to the federal and state governments. This is a fact.

Therefore, if the government of the day is not interested at all in implementing these reforms and to make the legislatures independent from the executive control, then corruption in government would become even more rampant.

As for the MACC chief commissioner and his senior officials, if you all want to complain and demonstrate your frustration over the rampant (and increased) corruption in this country, express it first to all those top politicians up there, instead of voicing it out to the press or the public. The people will just retort that you are powerless and ineffective.

Happy 53rd anniversary, MACC!

Source: g-socialaffairs.blogspot.com

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
7 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dr. SNaidu
Dr. SNaidu
20 Oct 2020 2.04pm

POLARISATION IN MULTIICULT’L SOCIETIES CAN SUCCUMB TO AND WEAPONISE ONE-ETHNIC MAJORITY POLICIES TO ‘INADVERTENTLY’ DESTROY THE LARGER WHOLE-THE NATION.WE SEE EGS IN THE FORMER RUSSIAN STATES IN EASTERN EUROPE, AFRICA, ASIA. WE NEED TO BE ON OUR GUARD. TRANSFORMING OUR EDN SYSTM,FOR UNIVERSAL PUBLIC VALUES, ATTITUDES,MONITORING BUSINESS CONCERNS, POLICE, CIVIL SERVICE CLOSELY N REALLY STRICTLY, CAN HELP IN MSIA’S TRAJECTORY FORWARD.SOCIALILLS,ONE-RACE POLICIES, ARE DESTROYING US. DR.M IS ON RECORD THAT Ms R DESTROYED, SO TOO SOME OTHERS TODAY, WITH THEIR SHORTSIGHTEDNESS CLAMOURING FOR POWER.NOT FOR KG, ESTATE RAKYAT’S WELL-BEING,N OUR YOUTH TO HAVE A SECURE, PROMISING FUTURE. WE TRULY NEED A NEW BUMIPUTERAISM FOR MSIA, FOR ALL CITIZENS..

Dr.Suranthiran Naidu
Dr.Suranthiran Naidu
14 Oct 2020 2.26pm

Thinking of ways of the resolution of this social ill,the PM, Parliament NEEDS to be inclusive.This is as provided for by the SPIRIT of OUR F.CONSTITUTION, RUKUN NEGARA.MACC and all PUBLIC appointments,NEED to be from ALL MALAYSIAN ethnic groups.This can be a check on the … what has sadly developed in M-based public service, for OUR nation going FORWARD.SARAWAK,SABAH, SINGAPORE,HONG KONG models of GOVERNANCE as such, can be used as guides.Nation’s education system NEEDS to be revisited, towards ensuring BM is the PRIMARY language of instruction.Vernacular schs MUST be merged into the mainstream, while retaining their educational status.NATIONHOOD VALUES for YOUNG via BM, ENG.,mother tongue languages NEED to be our burning focus.

Hakimi Abdul Jabar
14 Oct 2020 11.25am

BUSINESS & HUMAN RIGHTS & INDEPENDENT PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN

I run a registered legitimate business entity as its founder, global legal advisor, chief software developer and consultant.

In June 2011, the Human Rights Council had adopted the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (‘the Guiding Principles’). They emphasise the duty of the State to protect human rights; ensure that other actors respect human rights; and ensure access to remedy in the case of violation of rights.

The Malaysian police is an organ of the state and thus, under the duty to ensure not only the protection but also the enjoyment of my human rights.

Malaysia should have an Independent Parliamentary Ombudsman like Finland.

Hakimi Abdul Jabar
14 Oct 2020 9.58am

Aliran members and Friends of Suaram may realize that the police force falls under the jurisdiction of the executive not under an independent judiciary nor the legislature.

Thus, we must fully uphold the binding decision of the superbly brilliant Federal Court in Indira Gandhi that the power to review the lawfulness of executive action, which includes police misconduct, abuse, lackadaisical wantonness etc., rests solely with the civil courts.

Hakimi Abdul Jabar
14 Oct 2020 9.39am

As a member of ALIRAN, I’d propose to fellow members that the prevention of police misconduct should be an urgent priority, especially when law enforcement is under such acute scrutiny worldwide. Responses to Covid-19 – as well as greater scrutiny of police violence from Hong Kong to the United States – is a reminder to Malaysians that we need to implement checks against police misconduct. It is a historic opportunity to enact change.

Acts of police misconduct may also arise due to persons holding constitutional positions and/or executive interventions, orders of higher-ups etc.

The IGP and the entire police force must be made accountable to Parliament through select committees.

Gursharan Singh
Gursharan Singh
13 Oct 2020 10.21am

When worldwide leaders in power be they in politics-corporations-religions- professions-charities-societies and respective enforcement authorities are suspected or perceived to be involved corruption is it possible that there will be anyone in power to tackle corruption especially when
GREED MAY BE THE MAIN CAUSE OF LACK OF ACTION?

Could it be that CALLS FOR TACKLING CORRUPTION MAY HAVE JUST A P R ISSUE AND OF ACADEMIC INTEREST?

It may also be among major contributor to employment opportunities as well as for in enforcement accounting audit training legal and other professions.

CORRUPTION MAY BE AMONG THE MOST COMMON AND CONVENIENT AND SAFEST MEANS OF ACQUIRING WEALTH ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE IN POSITIONS OF POWER AND AUTHORITY.
Bless all

loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
13 Oct 2020 5.08am

The buck stops here!
The backdoor PM is on record of using juicy appointments to GLCs to bolster his support – so if the head honcho engages in corrupt practices , it becomes a matter of follow the leader.
Yes, WH Cheng as long as the political will is not there, corruption will continue to be the scourge of our government.
I do not think it is an overstatement but I truly believe our nation has fallen so far behind our small southern neighbour, in no small part because of this rampant corruption that goes all the way to the top echelons of our government.