A khat too deep in fault lines of multi-ethnic Malaysia?

1
156

Priority should be given to highlighting connectedness among the various ethnic groups in the wider context of forging national unity and mutual respect, says Mustafa K Anuar.

A controversy is now raging over the proposed introduction of khat, which is supposedly religion-neutral, to primary four pupils where race and religion are often mixed and exploited by certain quarters to the extent of giving rise to unsavoury consequences.

Even if khat (or Arabic calligraphy) is proposed with the most noble of intentions, which supposedly aims to help pupils to appreciate the art form as well as moral values, its hurried introduction has already created suspicion and anxiety particularly among non-Muslims.

It is possible that this issue might even alienate Pakatan Harapan from non-Malay constituencies at the next general election.

This is because it is introduced in a social context where Islamisation is perceived, rightly or wrongly, especially by non-Muslims, to have crept into national schools in the last few decades.

The khat poser is seen as yet another attempt to Islamise vernacular schools by reaching out to non-Muslim children.

It does not help either when Education Minister Maszlee Malik himself is depicted, rightly or otherwise, by his detractors as a keen advocate of Islamisation.

Furthermore, the khat introduction is made on the back of the government’s refusal so far to officially recognise the Unified Examination Certificate (UEC), which Chinese educationists in particular and the Chinese community in general have been clamouring for.

To be sure, recognising the UEC was part of the PH electoral manifesto in the last general election. It is also a move fervently pushed by the Chinese-dominated DAP, a component party of PH.

READ MORE:  Have mercy on our students first

In other words, the trustworthiness of the present government has been found wanting in the eyes of the affected non-Malays, particularly over khat and the UEC.

At the same time, certain Malay-Muslim groups and the opposition Umno-Pas have urged the federal government to stand its ground on the inclusion of khat into the syllabus.

A failure to do so would be deemed as the PH government’s, particularly Malay-based Bersatu’s, dismal inability to protect and promote Malay-Muslim culture and identity.

In short, the PH government has found itself caught between a rock and a hard place – which obviously isn’t comforting in its attempt to try and appease the two opposing blocs. Lo and behold, a zero-sum game is at play here.

Politics aside, the inclusion of the khat section – a mere six pages of the Bahasa Melayu textbook itself – brings into question the aim of this controversial change.

For example, can this brief introduction to khat be effective enough to make the pupils appreciate the art form at such an early age? Or would it just be a mere fleeting fancy for the children?

Can they really learn moral values by writing and using the following words – helpful, gift, caring, biological mother and good-hearted – in their Malay equivalent in Jawi?

Wouldn’t moral values be effectively instilled in a form that is familiar to the kids, namely the Romanised Malay language and the inclusion of other important values as well?

If the rationale behind introducing khat is to expose pupils to Arabic calligraphy, wouldn’t it be more appropriate to place it in, say, a separate booklet on Malaysia’s ethnic cultures, which showcases all forms of calligraphy that are found in our society, including Chinese, Indian, other ethnic and, if any, aboriginal ones?

READ MORE:  The remarkable school in Sungai Ara that Maszlee would dream of

By doing so, each of the calligraphic forms would be provided its proper social context while children would be made to recognise these diverse art forms are part and parcel of being Malaysian – and they should celebrate this rich diverse heritage.

The aim here is clearly not to dilute the political and cultural identity of people from each of the ethnic groups in the country. It is to give priority to connectedness between ethnic groups in the wider context of forging national unity and mutual respect.

Neither does this approach necessarily denigrate the position of the Malay language as the national language. On the contrary, its status would be enhanced when used to help pupils to access knowledge about their country’s heritage, one of which is khat and the Jawi script.

It is hoped that this strategy would help build a vital sense of belonging among children and their parents as well and not develop fear of cultural marginalisation and political exclusion.

Equally, if not more, important is the need for the Ministry of Education to clearly state its overall objective of having educational reform and academic changes, such as khat, in the larger context of national unity and progress.

Source: themalaysianinsight.com

Thanks for dropping by! Apart from the views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed, the opinions in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation of whatever amount you can afford to sustain Aliran. Please make payments to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.

And why not become an Aliran member or subscribe to our FREE newsletters.

1
Join the conversation

avatar
750
1 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
1 Comment authors
SNaidu, Dr. Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
SNaidu, Dr.
SNaidu, Dr.

Slm perp’dn.Tq sir.A few humble thoughts for our evolution in further connectedness. 1.Pls recognise the UEC. BM grade can be the official condition.This was promised a few times.Do not alienate the Ch Msns further.2.Any ednl growth needs to INVOLVE ALL GRPS.As a national democracy, DO consult-get feedback from the people first. There is no excuse today. Soc media-modern technology can help 3.Cultural traditions are essentially immutable.RESPECT all.They go back a long way. Adaptations, possible n do occur.4.Sense of belonging to MSIA is greatly crucial, starting with OUR youth.5.EDUCATE youth, society in nationhood values,real natl history, as through BM,ENG, Moral-Agama studies.OUR natl heritage can be SOWN-Islam, etc, meaningfully.