Param Cumaraswamy pays tribute to the late Raja Aziz Addruse, a lawyer of high integrity who shone as a beacon in the Malaysian bar at a time when the independence of the judiciary was threatened.
Yang Mulia Raja Abdul Aziz Addruse, affectionately known to his colleagues as Ungku, passed away on 12 July 2011 after a short illness at his home and was laid to rest at the Bukit Kiara cemetery the following day.
Born in Chemor, Perak on 10 February 1936, he received his secondary school education at Anderson School in Ipoh. He then read law at the University of Bristol and, after graduation, was called to the English Bar at Lincoln’s Inn in 1960. One of his contemporaries in Bristol was Tan Sri L C Vohrah.
On his return to Malaysia in 1960, he served in the Attorney General’s Chambers for a short period as a Public Prosecutor and later as deputy parliamentary draftsman. In January 1966, he was admitted to the Malaysian Bar and entered into private practice together with Tengku Ahmad Rithauddeen Ismail. The firm then was known as Rithauddeen & Aziz. Among those who practised in that firm were Mohamed Dzaiddin Abdullah (who later became the Chief Justice of Malaysia and was conferred a Tunship), Yaacob Merican, Zainur Zakaria, Wan Ariff Hamzah, Johari Razak and Zaid Ibrahim.
Commanded respect from the judges
His eminence in advocacy before the Courts and the respect he commanded from the Judges earned him a reputation, and soon he was in demand in the profession as lead counsel. That led him to confine his practice to counsel work before the civil and criminal courts. His knowledge of the law and commitment to fairness in any given cause drew him to accept appointments to arbitrate on civil disputes.
When Lord President Tun Mohd Suffian first introduced the appointment of temporary judicial commissioners to clear then backlog of cases in the High Court, Raja Aziz was one of the few appointed. But he refused any permanent judicial appointment. He felt that only through practice of the law could he contribute effectively to the advancement of the cause of justice through respect for the rule of law and human rights. His commitment to these causes was remarkable.
He was also throughout involved in the advancement of an independent legal profession in Malaysia. He served as President of the Malaysian Bar in 1976-1978; again in 1988-1989 and once again in 1992-1993. That was unprecedented. Returned thrice by popular call from within the profession to lead the profession.
He sought, pursued and set high standards for lawyers in the country. In the early 1970s, he was involved in the drafting of the present Legal Profession Act (LPA). His personality is reflected in the first objective of the Malaysian Bar as provided in Section 42 of LPA “to uphold the cause of justice without regard to its own interest or that of its members, uninfluenced by fear or favour”.
Professional, fair-minded and ethical
He was so professional, fair minded and ethical that having him as the opposing counsel was always a pleasure in litigation before the courts. He was seen and heard in the forefront with advocacy groups outside courts and as lead counsel in the courts over human rights violations. He gave voice to the voiceless, taking on their causes on pro-bono briefs before the courts to assist those who could not afford access to the courts.
In 1977 I had the privilege of serving as the Bar Council Secretary when he was the President. In his absence overseas the authorities began investigation on me for an offence of sedition when I published an open appeal to the Prime Minister, then Tun Hussein Onn, to review the Essential Security Cases Regulations when a 14-year-old school boy was sentenced to death for possession of a revolver. Raja Aziz on his return was flabbergasted on learning that his Council Secretary was subjected to such an investigation. He immediately wrote two stern letters to the Prime Minister and the Attorney General, then Kadir Yusof, not to harass and intimidate the Bar Secretary. No prosecution was preferred against me.
However, when in 1985 I was charged for sedition in connection with the open appeal to the Pardons Board over the commutation of death sentence of Sim Kie Chon, Raja Aziz was my lead defence counsel. After a six-day trial, in a landmark judgment on freedom of expression, I was acquitted by Justice N H Chan. In the course of trial, the judge commended Raja Aziz’s presentation of the defence.
In 1988, when Tun Salleh Abbas, then Lord President, was suspended and subjected to tribunal for misconduct, Raja Aziz was sought to lead the defence. He was then President of the Bar. He again maintained the high ethics of the Bar. As counsel he did not want to be seen leading the Bar’s public protest over that crisis which was then developing. He left the leadership of the protest to the Vice President.
The eventual dismissal of Tun Salleh Abbas and three other independent judges of the Supreme Court left Raja Aziz disenchanted with the independence of the Malaysian judiciary. Reading the slants and half truths and distortions in the book Judicial Misconduct written by a New Zealand Queens Counsel, Peter Williams, in defence of the conduct by all those involved in the assault of the independent judges, he could not resist a response. He wrote a book ‘Conduct Unbecoming’ giving a honest ringside account of what happened and demolished Peter Williams account into shreds.
Refused to appear before Hamid Omar
During Tun Hamid Omar’s tenure as Lord President, Raja Aziz refused to appear before him in any appeals as a mark of protest and his lack of confidence in the system because of Hamid’s conduct in those events. He felt that the justice system had not recovered from those events. He laboured this feeling as recent as last year when acting for the Sultan of Kelantan before the Federal Court. That was his last case. He was receiving treatment in Singapore then. He was determined to argue the case of His Royal Highness personally before that Court. His assisting counsel presented a medical certificate and sought a postponement for a short period of time to enable him to appear personally. The court refused. That was a sore disappointment to him.
Earlier in 1998, when he was lead counsel for Dato Seri Anwar Ibrahim in the alleged corruption trial before Justice Augustine Paul, on learning that the judge had capitulated to executive pressure in the trial process, Raja Aziz did not mince his words when he said in a public statement that ‘This trial is no longer the trial of Dato Seri Anwar Ibrahim alone. The Malaysian judiciary is on trial.’
In addition to all his contributions to advancement of the Rule of Law through the judicial process and advocacy of the legal profession, Raja Aziz found time to join like-minded concerned personalities to set up and lead non-governmental organisations (NGOs).
In 1989, together with two Prime Ministers, Tunku Abdul Rahman and Tun Hussein Onn, and me, Raja Aziz applied for registration of The National Human Rights Association (now known as Hakam) under the Societies Act. It was the first human rights NGO to be registered in Malaysia. Raja Aziz was its first chairman.
In 1990 concerned that the general election would not be free and fair, he was one of the six members led by Tun Mohd Suffian to form Election Watch, which earned the wrath of Dr. Mahathir Mohammed then Prime Minister.
Together with Tunku Abdul Aziz, Anwar Fazal and me, Raja Aziz also assisted in setting up and having Transparency International Malaysia registered as a society.
His relentless and committed pursuit of justice through the rule of law was noted by the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), the global advocate of the rule of law based in Geneva. Its Commissioners are eminent jurists identified and elected from across the regions. Raja Aziz was elected as a Commissioner in 2006. The earlier two Commissioners from Malaysia were Tun Mohd Suffian and me. After his appointment, he often lamented to me that he just did not have sufficient time to contribute more to the ICJ. The ICJ, however, valued his contributions and extended deep condolences to his family.
His integrity throughout was beyond question. On 11 April 2010 he was awarded the Lifetime Professional Integrity Award by the Malaysian Professional Centre together with Rotary International District 3300 and Integrity International Malaysia at a ceremony at the Royal Selangor Club.
Raja Aziz did not only pursue the high values of the legal profession but he indeed personified these values. His passing marks the passing of an era – a high water mark in the struggle for a just rule of law, judicial and lawyer independence and human rights in Malaysia. His passing is not just a loss to his loving family but to the profession and the nation.
Raja Aziz leaves behind his wife Catherine, two daughters Azriene and Adeline, sons-in-law Jonathan and Craig, and a grandson, Cassidy.
Dato’ Param Cumaraswamy was Chair of the Malaysian Bar Council from 1986 to 1988 and United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers by the UN Commission on Human Rights from 1994 to 2003.
|Thanks for dropping by! You are one of an increasing number of readers looking up Aliran for independent analyses and views. We work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to continue the struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. So would you consider making a donation to keep us going - or why not become an Aliran member or subscribe to our FREE newsletters.|