Why is Muhyiddin still thinking of emergency rule to stop polls?

2
391 views

Many in Sabah would thank the PM if there is a no-contest in the Batu Sapi by-election, Jem writes.

Wasn’t it just a dozen days ago that the Agong denied a controversial request by the Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin and his team to declare a state of emergency in the country?

The Agong, in a statement on 25 October by the comptroller of the royal household, noted the government was handling the coronavirus pandemic effectively and reminded all politicians to stop any politicking that would disrupt the nation’s administration.

“The King and the eight Rulers felt it is important to respect the check-and-balance mechanism between the various branches of government, and the role of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, which is to balance various demands to ensure justice and to check any abuse of power,” the keeper of the ruler’s seal said later that day.

Three days later, in another statement issued by the comptroller of the royal household, the King urged all MPs to support Budget 2021.

Now, I would have thought that those words would have been enough for anyone to sit up and take notice!

But judging by the PM’s recent speech where he again indicated his desire for a state of emergency, it would seem he did not get the message. He said this was the only way to stop further elections for fear of a fresh outbreak of the pandemic. The Batu Sapi by-election in Sabah is coming up soon and the Sarawak state election must be held by 2021.

Note that this speech was given just a week after the PM’s failed attempt to obtain the King’s consent to declare a state of emergency.

READ MORE:  Focus on the people; no emergency, please! – 91 academics

Haven’t we all been told that we must respect the King? So what is the prime minister saying to the rakyat?

What did Muhyiddin mean when he said, “But what can we do because that is a requirement in the Federal Constitution that we have to hold elections. Unless Emergency is declared under Article 150 of the Federal Constitution in Batu Sapi and Sarawak, we can postpone these two elections until Covid-19 ends.”

The PM added that if “if the Sarawak State Election were to be held, he [the health director general] was worried that the rural areas of Sarawak which do not have complete health facilities would not be able to accommodate the increase in positive Covid-19 cases that would likely rise sharply after the election.”

Note that the Sarawak state election can be legally delayed until August 2021.

So is the prime minister speaking about elections in the East Malaysian states or the one that may or may not be called in the peninsula?

The nomination day for the Batu Sapi by-election in Sabah is on 23 November with polling on 5 December. The seat fell vacant on 2 October, upon the death of incumbent Liew Vui Keong.

So will the by-election in Sabah be used as an excuse to revisit the state of emergency scenario?

As the by-election is coming up soon, what should be done? Will it go on despite the pandemic or will the government heed Umno deputy president Mohamad Hassan’s advice: “It is known that BN will not contest in Batu Sapi and I urge other parties to also give way to Warisan to win uncontested. It is a way to pay our respects to the late Liew and to avoid having an election at a time like this.”

READ MORE:  Emergency declaration defers Batu Sapi by-election - but other polls loom

The people of Batu Sapi and of Sabah will certainly thank Mohamad Hassan and all the other parties who have decided not to contest in this by-election. This will help to prevent the pandemic from spreading.

If the Umno deputy president’s advice is ignored and the by-election goes ahead, it would be of great benefit to the health and wellbeing of the people in Batu Sapi if politicians from Kuala Lumpur did not go stomping around in Batu Sapi, to make their voices heard. They have enough people in Sabah to do their bidding.

The Ministry of Health must also come up with more stringent measures for politicians and voters to comply with. If that can be enforced, the rise in Covid-19 cases might be less than expected.

The people in Batu Sapi can then perform civic duty and vote without fear. It can be done as Singapore and New Zealand have shown.

The thought of the country being placed under a state of emergency is just all wrong based on the evidence of what the nation is already doing. Is the country in such a bad shape to warrant it? A state of emergency would have terrible consequences for the economy, investors’ confidence, democracy and national unity. Is this what the people want?

So what could be the real reason for this? Is it really aimed at stopping elections in elections in Sabah and Sarawak? Or is that just a sideshow?

Is it to stop a snap election from being called in the peninsula? Despite Umno saying it would support the PM and his Perikatan Nasional government, the reality is Umno wants more power and a bigger say in the government. It wants better cooperation based on “respect’ and “political consensus” – that’s how the party puts it.

READ MORE:  Having the cake and eating it too, in Sabah

The prime minister will be hard-pressed to deny Umno’s requests, for fear of the party walking away and supporting somebody else.

There is the added fear of a no-confidence vote in Parliament, which is currently sitting, and the uncertainty over whether Budget 2021 will be passed.

Instead of being a responsible prime minister and rallying the people to fight the third wave of the pandemic, he appears to be prioritising himself. This is the political reality in Malaysia now, and the PM is caught in a cleft stick of his own making!

If Mohamad Hassan’s advice is heeded, the people of Batu Sapi and the rest of Sabah would be very appreciative of the PM’s thoughtfulness, especially during this pandemic.

Jem, an Aliran reader, still cares deeply about Sabah, despite having lived in the peninsula for some time

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dr. SNaidu
Dr. SNaidu
9 Nov 2020 1.06pm

Things can n NEED to change in OUR beloved nation.Racism-bumiputeraism NEED to end. OUR F.Constitution NEED to be adhered to at all times. BUT, its spirit of multiculturalism NEED to be brought to the fore,for OUR YOUTH for the future of OUR nation.Th e ‘monster’civil service must be checked.ALL citizen races must occupy senior positions.These are simple, real common solutions.We know other nations as stated, Sing., N Zealand did well in their elections. OUR leader-servants-politicians NEED to search their souls, before it is too late for this nation.Americans hv cried n brought about the changes, for the BETTER prayerfully n positively.WE NEED to’educate’ ourselves in GOd, for the RIGHT for MSIA.

loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
7 Nov 2020 6.33am

“It can be done as Singapore and New Zealand have shown.”
Thank you, Jem for highlighting these 2 examples – national elections has been successfully conducted there with no spike in covid 19 infections.
We only had the Sabah state elections and we are faced with the spike in infections. Why? SOPs to prevent covid 19 infections were not enforced, politicians are above the law , quarantines were not enforced until after the elections – so the nation is paying the price now for the dereliction of duty by the Health Ministry.
Yes, I know it is not fair to blame the Health Ministry – the backdoor govt. is to blame.