Whisky Timah and the Prophet’s daughter: Is there any connection as some idiots think?

We have been referring to tin as timah ever since tin was discovered, and no foolish person in the past had associated that name with a person

3,081 views
How did this controversy happen? - FACEBOOK

A locally brewed whisky has won accolades overseas and a silver medal in an international competition in 2019. But here, on home ground, it has received brickbats.

A few urban-based misguided and misinformed half-baked politicians have kicked up so much dust as if it was a matter of life and death. While these urbanites are frothing in the mouth, the kampong Malays take life easy and lead their lives as they have always done – live and let live, minding their own business.

The kampong Malay doesn’t drink whisky, and he understands it is haram to drink. He doesn’t care who else drinks because others drinking whisky does not disturb his own lifestyle or affect his way of life.

But some narrow-minded and not-that-smart politicians have worked themselves up into a frenzy because this award-winning whisky was named Timah. We have been referring to tin as timah for ages ever since tin was discovered, and no foolish person in the past had associated that name with a person. It was understood that the word referred to a metal – tin. Suddenly timah, it seems, is short for Fatimah – not for any Fatimah but for the Prophet’s daughter Fatimah. How ridiculous can one get!

The image of a person on the label of the whisky bottle is taken as an insult to Islam, offending the Muslims. How on earth did this happen? We’ve come across thousands of images that can resemble many personages from the past. Nobody has made a fuss about them. So what if a person sports a beard and wears a skull cap. How does he insult Islam? Will the scatterbrains clarify how this particular image on the whisky bottle specifically insults Islam?

READ MORE:  Whitewashing Timah is no solution

Is the dignity of Islam reflected in what a person wears and how he looks – many wonder in amazement!

Fatimah is an Arabic name; it is not an exclusive name for Prophet Muhammad’s daughter. It is an ordinary name. Indeed, previously several relatives of Prophet Muhammad had the same name. It is a name that was common throughout the Arabic world.

It is also a female name commonly used among Roman Catholics, particularly in the Portuguese-speaking and Spanish-speaking world. Most people would have heard of the Lady of Fatima and many Catholics make a pilgrimage to her sanctuary in the town of Fatima in Portugal in reverence.

Christians had the good sense not to associate this Fatima with the Timah whisky! They won’t be that foolish to link a revered person to something they may despise. They respect and maintain the high esteem these figures are accorded.

But not so with these few fanatical Muslims in Malaysia who are hell-bent on causing mischief. Out of the thousands of Fatimahs all over the world, how did these bigots and idiots associate the daughter of Prophet Muhammad with the whisky? That is a million-dollar question! What ingenious method did these perverts employ to associate Prophet Muhammad’s daughter to the Timah whiskey? Shame on them for stooping so low for political purposes!

If there was only one Fatimah in the world, then you can rightly and accurately associate this person with the whisky. But there are thousands of them and how, pray tell, was the Prophet’s daughter picked solely to be associated with this whisky?

READ MORE:  Curbs on alcohol and gaming: Blinkered approach to tackling social concerns

Normally, revered figures are associated with things that represent purity, that are just and right, and which reflect moral values. But here, these perverts associate the Prophet’s daughter with something that is evil, sinful and forbidden. Aren’t they aware that by doing so, they have sullied the name of the Prophet’s daughter and insulted Islam?

And yet, they blame the producers of Timah for the insult. The guilty ones misrepresenting the issue and creating uneasiness and stirring up religious conflict are these obnoxious characters parading as defenders of Islam! These are not Muslims who, according to Islam, should be setting the example for unity among the communities and harmony in the way of our life. These are the disrupters and spoilers who spew venom and lie for their personal gain in politics.

Lest we Malaysians forget amidst all the needless hullabaloo that focuses on the inconsequential, can we say that the local whisky producer is just selling its concept of ‘adventure’ and not mere liquor, just as the famous watch maker is selling ‘prestige’ and not mere Rolex watches.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Paul Lim
Paul Lim
1 Nov 2021 3.00am

Will adding Bukit help calm things down? Bukit Timah in Singapore.

Jam tangan
Jam tangan
30 Oct 2021 2.58am

The idea is to stay in power weaponizing religion. UMNO and PAS can only stay in power if they misrepresent that they are the stewards of Islam and the Malay identity. The whole world can see the HARAM written on the foreheads of [some] UMNO and PAS members…

Today, every democratic intuition that protects Malaysians has been dismantled thanks to the ‘Father of Corruption & Segregation’ and carried passed on to his 40 thieves.

PAS has said that “Corruption is not a crime” openly reported internationally for all to see and laugh…