Time for Malays to take the bull by the horns

Instead of pitting one race against another, we should consider policies that allow the different races to work together as supporting partners

1,225 views
WONG SOAK KOON/ALIRAN

In recent weeks, a numbing sense of hopelessness has overwhelmed many of us.

Race, religion and fear are being played out against a backdrop of rising Covid infections in a sea of political chaos, generated by a near absent leadership.

It is as if we are looking at ruins after a war. Our educational institutions are crumbling; unemployment and poverty rates are rising; and above all, there is hardly any semblance of a working democratic system. 

The people have never been more divided by race and fear. On one side of the fence, there is fear of losing political power, and cultural and religious identity. On the other, it is the fear of radical Islamisation and of losing economic and cultural relevance.

Nestled between these two sides is an unmistakable awareness of inequalities and deep-seated insecurities over capacities, talent, skills, opportunities, education, culture, religion and wealth. Research has shown that feelings of inequalities and insecurities are issues that will need to be addressed to restore a sense of equilibrium and prosperity.

It has been well documented that people who feel marginalised and insecure in an unequal world desperately seek a semblance of order, control and predictability in their lives. And to regain order, they would usually fall on either of two things: religion and conspiracy theories. This is not particular to Malaysia and plays out, even in the US.

In Malaysia there is a religious shift; a sense that extremist religious movements, championed by influencers such as Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin, are gaining ground.

In addition, more religious subjects are taught in schools; more religious rules and practices are seen in workplaces; and Islamic dress codes are applied, even in police stations. 

As for conspiracy theories, we are certainly people who are more likely to believe in conspiracy theories than to seek evidence or scientific verification. One popular conspiracy theory carelessly tossed about is that most misfortunes in Malaysia are masterminded by the DAP.

READ MORE:  Rape jokes aren't OK

Another was proposed by the book Pendedahan Agenda Kristian (Exposing the Christian Agenda) by an anonymous writer. The book alleges that a grand secret Christian conspiracy is threatening the position of Islam in the country.

The truth of these claims has never been proven. The alleged perpetrators, whether from the DAP or the many Christian movements, have never been investigated or arrested nor have any documents been submitted to the police.

Fears and insecurities are not new. They have always been there and have even determined some of the clauses enshrined in our Constitution. The affirmative action policies – the New Economic Policy and the National Development Policy – were intended to remove these, but they didn’t.

In carrying out these policies over the last five decades, invisible walls have been erected, segregating the races and creating racial silos in government and even in the private sector.

Although there are many exceptions, those who are locked within these mono-ethnic silos are often insulated from functioning optimally in collaborative cross-racial environments.

Within these silos, insecurities and perceptions about inequalities have continued to grow. Racial distrust is also tossed in by politicians, peddling more fear, insecurities and even hatred. 

The undercurrents of insecurities and perceptions of inequalities are so strong that it is believed that if the Malay privileges and benefits are to stop, their world would crash. This was probably part of the underlying impetus for the Sheraton Move.

Many hardline Malay politicians may even have come to realise that they have wedged the Malays between a rock and a hard place, unable to let go of these privileges and fearing, and that they may not be able to hold on.

READ MORE:  Mission schools contributed immensely to Malaysia's education system

Clearly the old ways have not worked. Experts, psychologists and economists would know better what needs to be done. I, for one, am not an expert but here is my two cents worth.

I may want to consider more practical collaborative options that open up schools, educational institutions and other places of employment to enable confidence to grow by putting students and employees in safe supported environments of collaborative learning.

Instead of pitting one race against another, we should consider policies that allow the different races to work together as supporting partners. We should build multiracial learning teams in a variety of different contexts both in the government sector and the private.

Learning in English may also be a game changer. I met an elderly Malay man in his seventies who explained to me in fluent English how, in the 1950s, he had transitioned from a rural Malay school in three years to a racially mixed class in an English school.

English had helped him to broaden his world and had given him confidence to interact with others. Yet, he has not lost his Malay identity. He is still passionately religious. 

Perhaps we could transition a few national schools into English schools but within the vicinity of the rural Malay heartland, where the religious and cultural influences can still continue to flow. Perhaps it is time to begin learning and living without fear.

There is much that can be done, but none of this can happen, if the Malays themselves do not initiate these changes to fix our broken systems. It should not come from the non-Malays. That would be like setting fire to tinder.

READ MORE:  Forum: Pelajar saman guru/The students that sued the teachers

This may seem like a near impossible scenario, yet Ain Husniza Saiful Nizam has shown us that it can be done. Countless others who have stepped forward to support her. have shown us it can be done.

There is also a young Malay girl who spoke out fearlessly in a YouTube video about police brutality against ethnic Indian detainees. She too has shown us it can be done. In her video, she appeals to the Malays to begin a conversation about race.

The young seem to know. They want to vote and have a say. They are breaking down racial lines and are already learning to work together. The leader must listen.

Our leaders need to know that, if nothing is done, many Malaysians, especially those in the middle and lower-income groups (and the other marginalised people) will have to pay the heavy price of dying as dinosaurs. They cannot afford to hold on to fear.

The world is fast becoming a highly competitive and evolving environment. The future will demand that we learn to reinvent ourselves again and again, even as we stand on our feet. 

Change must come mainly from the Malays, who must rise and become agents of change. They must fearlessly take the bull by the horns and right the wrongs that have been done by a few old men who have long outlived their time.

Sukeshini Nair was a teacher in government schools for over three decades before becoming principal of a secondary school until her retirement

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
16 May 2021 4.57pm

I took a look at the article’s title and its author – and sorry for throwing a wet blanket, but no matter what gems of wisdom are contained within, the Malays will do no such thing.
Even progressive Malays like Khairil and Zaid, have been careful not to touch this topic of education with a ten foot pole.
I apologise to parents who have no options but to swallow the fare they dish out, but for those who can afford to, please do get an education overseas.

Sukeshini Nair
Sukeshini Nair
18 May 2021 12.06am

This is the real problem!! We are too overcome by negativism and by fear!! We are a nation too petrified to start a reasonable rational conversation with our Malay friends and colleagues about race and education. Let’s find out more about their perspective, find out what is wrong? What can be right? As long as we stay silent and passive, there will be no hope!

This is the only way to have more voices join the fray; not from the top but from the bottom, to start the conversations in small groups. It will not be easy and it may be messy but it is a place to start. We all need to do our small part, take one small proactive step to come out of this tight circle of fear. Have we? Have you?

Last edited 28 days ago by Sukeshini Nair