He quit after arriving late at the House of Lords: Would our frequently absent MPs do likewise?


Perhaps Malaysian MPs and ministers’ uninterrupted hold on power has made them take their peers in Parliament and voters for granted, writes Anil Netto.

A member of the UK House of Lords sparked disbelief when he resigned after being a couple of minutes late and for not being at his place to answer a question from a peer.

International Development Minister Michael Bates began calmly enough when he said:

I want to offer my sincere apologies to Baroness Lister for my discourtesy in not being in my place to answer her question on a very important matter at the beginning of questions.

During the five years in which it’s been my privilege to answer questions from this dispatch box on behalf of the government, I’ve always believed that we should rise to the highest possible standards of courtesy and respect in responding on behalf of the government to the legitimate questions of the legislature.

Then came the shocker:

I am thoroughly ashamed at not being in my place and therefore I shall be offering my resignation to the prime minister . . . with immediate effect.

He then left the house, leaving behind stunned peers, some of whom exclaimed in disbelief, “No! No!”

A friend of mine wrote to me: “Can this (a resignation for arriving late in Parliament) happen here?”

READ MORE:  Where is the Speaker’s independence? He merely followed the BN script!

“In your dreams,” I replied, as long as there is no change.

Here, we have members of Parliament, even ministers, absenting themselves even during crucial votes or when they should be in the house to provide an answer or explanation.

Of course, for Bates to resign over being slightly late on this occasion was a bit drastic. “But it shows his character, his sense on duty and accountability; his humility; and sense of shame even at such a minor infraction,” said a KL-based political observer. “It is an example of the real meaning of leadership, which is to serve and not lord (pun intended) it over others.”

Never mind slight tardiness, not a few of our members of Parliament and ministers are frequently absent altogether or missing from the house, inexplicably unavailable to personally answer questions related to their portfolios. “With their sense of entitlement, arrogance lack of accountability, they are the polar opposites of Bates,” he said.

Perhaps these Malaysian ministers and MPs’ uninterrupted hold on power has made them take their peers in Parliament and voters for granted.

Postscript: Bates was later persuaded to remain in his post.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed here are the writer's personal views and do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position, which can be found in our media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed or are a part of.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to continue the struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. So would you consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, Maybank account number: 507246118995.

And why not become an Aliran member or subscribe to our FREE newsletters.
Anil Netto
Anil Netto, the honorary treasurer of Aliran, is constantly amazed at how Aliran miraculously keeps afloat financially. A former corporate finance head and external auditor, he believes in social justice for all and environmental stewardship.

Join the conversation

1 Comment on "He quit after arriving late at the House of Lords: Would our frequently absent MPs do likewise?"

newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Yap Bin Chun

Malaysia! Hahahahaha.