It will happen with or without the Speaker’s help: The backdoor government will fall!

4
7,563 views
Photograph: Wikimedia Commons

Majority support for the Muhyiddin Yassin-led government must be put to the test so that there is a basis for him to act in his capacity as Prime Minister, P Ramakrishnan writes.

There are 27 motions waiting to decide the fate of the backdoor government.

They are demanding to know the status of the present government. Both the Opposition (25 motions) as well as the government MPs (two motions) are seemingly anxious to know if Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin enjoys the confidence of Parliament. This issue deserves to be settled first so that the items on the order paper can proceed as intended after that. It is crucial that the legitimacy of the government be established first before government bills are tabled for debate. At this juncture, we don’t know the standing of Muhyiddin and his cabinet. Many think and believe he doesn’t have majority support to carry on the functions of a legitimate government. If so, that would make it an illegitimate government.

An illegitimate government doesn’t have the right to govern the country or decide policies for the nation. As long as this majority support is in doubt, and in the absence of any attempt by Muhyiddin to remove this doubt by submitting himself to a vote of confidence, Perikatan Nasional cannot claim to be the lawful government. The majority support must be put to test so that there is a basis for Muhyiddin to act in his capacity as Prime Minister.

Let it be understood that without the sanction of Parliament confirming Muhyiddin indeed has the authority to carry on the functions of a legitimate government, he has no right to be the head of the PN government. This dubious government has no right to table government bills for debate. If it turns out that Muhyiddin does not have majority support in Parliament, it will be wasted time and effort debating government bills first without settling his government’s legitimacy.

READ MORE:  Is there another way to settle Anwar’s claim of majority support? Yes, there is a simple solution!

If this simple logic does not persuade the Speaker to put these motions of confidence to vote at the start of Parliament sitting on 2 November 2020, he will not be viewed as a neutral person acting in the best interest of democracy. When both the Opposition and the ruling MPs earnestly seek to settle this issue of confidence, the Speaker should not be a stumbling block. He cannot simply ignore the fact these 27 motions represent more than 12% of the 222 MPs in parliament. This is a big number that cannot be dismissed – he must take cognisance of the percentage of MPs demanding for vote.

If the Speaker is adamant government business must take precedence – no doubt, that will be his stand – then the only thing left for all those who moved the motions of confidence – or no confidence – is to defeat Budget 2021. In one stroke, two objectives can be achieved: the Speaker who doesn’t understand the democratic process and the false government will be kicked out.

If the Speaker is prudent enough to allow the motions of confidence to be decided on the first day, nothing is lost. The new government will table its own Budget 2021. Normally, the Opposition will have ready its alternative budget to present. When the Opposition becomes the new government following the defeat of PN’s Budget 2021, their alternative budget will become Budget 2021. In essence, there will be a budget ready to be debated. There is nothing to worry.

If the Speaker is obstinate in sticking to his interpretation of the Standing Orders and disallows the debate on the motion of confidence, it will be a waste of precious time and effort when finally Budget 2021 is inevitably defeated. At that point, there will be no budget and there will be no government.

READ MORE:  Declare assets to enhance public trust

The Standing Orders are meant to regulate parliamentary proceedings. They are not cast in stone. They don’t have the authority of the constitution.

The Speaker must not be seen as standing in the way of democracy and obstructing the democratic process.

All MPs who are concerned that we must not be governed by an illegitimate government should heed Thomas Paine’s statement: “The duty of a true patriot is to protect his country from its government.”

Will our MPs live up to the dictates of their conscience? Or will it be politics as usual without principles and morality?

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Yellowwoman
Yellowwoman
1 Nov 2020 3.55pm

The PH MPs must do what is right to claim back the government we voted for. Do it. Claim what is ours. Recent events and efforts by so many parties strongly convinced me that Anwar has the numbers.

ramsey
ramsey
1 Nov 2020 2.50pm

If conscience is the criterion there would not be 70 ministers

Nawawi Mohamad
Nawawi Mohamad
31 Oct 2020 10.29pm

Nobody has the majority in parliament to form the government. At the moment there can never be a solid coalition. Anyone leading will only have a lose coalition who will face the same fate as Muhyidin/ PN. There is no alternative but to hold a general election. Anyway, we are already living in the new norm, so just face it.

loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
31 Oct 2020 5.59pm

Rama, as it stands now it is the Speaker,no doubt acting at the behest of the backdoor PM who is preventing a vote on the no confidence motion against the PM.
Yes, well said, Rama , when the dust settles, the rakyat will be able to see who among MPs has a conscience!