Immersion in reality would help resolve Allah conundrum


Through a spiritual approach in embracing and immersing ourselves in complex reality with love and compassion, we could liberate Malaysia from its current divisive situation, says Ronald Benjamin.

Allah controversry protest
Groups linked to Selangor Umno protest against the use of the word Allah by Christians – Photograph:

One of the most important cognitive and social attributes of leadership of any organisations is the ability to come up with solutions that are derived from immersion in reality.

One would not find solutions by speaking outside reality. For example, there are three types of cognitive thinking when a crisis arises.

The first type of person would like to make a distinction between him and reality by being aloof when a problem crops up. This person cries out for peace and stability from distance without wanting to know or understand the root cause of the crisis. He would support extreme authoritarian measures to safeguard elitist and individualistic interests.

The second cognitive process involves a person who would make an effort to understand reality, but she is tied by an ideological frame work which she believes would solve every problem. While there is a certain degree of good vision and value in this type of thinking, its shortcomings have to do with a reality deficit because it relies on rigid ideological formulations to solve problems. This can be seen in the ethno-centric religious parties and far left socialist-oriented organisations. Such ideologues whether from the right or left have limited understanding of complex realities.

The third type of cognitive process is embedded in deep spiritual truths, in which a person desires to immerse himself in complex realities while infused with the values of love compassion and reason. The ability to see the goodness in others even though there are differences of opinion marks this type of thinking. This person’s concept of justice goes beyond ethno-religious and secular-centric formulations; it tackles issues that create unjust systems and structures that violate human dignity and deny equality, creativity and progress. Universal traditional truths and maxims which unite rather than divide take precedence.

The basis for a dialogue is based on an understanding that human beings have diverse aspirations and expressions and there is a need to address and reconcile the concerns of all groups through a balanced approach, through the lens of seeing goodness in the others by embracing reality.

In the current context of the deepening rift between Muslims and Christians in Malaysia, it is important for political leaders and religious leaders to embrace the third type of cognitive process that is embedded in deep spiritual truths that embraces complex reality while acknowledging the goodness in others.

The Allah issue could be resolved if there an effort to understand and acknowledge the reality that Christianity is not a European-centric religion and Christians in Malaysia have been using the term Allah in their scriptures for centuries. For their part, Christians should acknowledge the reality that the identity of the majority of Malays in Malaysia is defined by Islam, which encompasses every aspect of their life and is reflected in the history of the nation. Fear of coveted attempts to convert others to one’s religion should be addressed based on evidence and reason and not based on mere suspicion.

The basis for a dialogue among relevant participants should be an understanding that even though religion is part of a socio-political system, it is vital to stress on substance rather than form. This would help focus on real issues of structural and systemic injustice that affect the common good.

Dialogue should be pursued with humility and intensity of purpose, grounded in reality without preconceived assumptions. Through a spiritual approach in embracing and immersing ourselves in complex reality with love and compassion, we could liberate Malaysia from the current divisive situation where religious extremists seem to dictate the course of the nation.

(Visited 13 times, 1 visits today)
Thanks for dropping by! You are one of an increasing number of readers looking up Aliran for independent analyses and views. We work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to continue the struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. So would you consider making a donation to keep us going - or why not become an Aliran member or subscribe to our FREE newsletters.


  1. Why don’t the Christians prove to these s….. that without using the word Allah the Christians will still be around till the end of time. Besides millions or billion of people became Christians not because they believe in Allah, a typical example is a Christian friend of mine who he did not even know what is the meaning of Allah when he was converted.

    Therefore just let these s….. have the exclusive use of the word Allah and see how far and how many non Muslims will then be converted. Theses Umno s…. have nothing more constructive or useful to come up with and as such is using this Allah issue to divert the attention of the people from many of the urgent matters facing this country. Such as the cutting down the many subsidizes or the implementation of the many new taxes. These are the real problems Malaysia is facing and not Allah or God, again it is just a diversion and please don’t be a fool and fall into the trap of these morons.

    How come the muslims and the non muslims, for over so many decades could go on living peacefully without a worry as to who can or cannot use the word. And are now fighting over the use of one word, besides the non muslims who are mainly non Malays by now should know the kind of s……. we have running the country. It is for this very reason why we are displaying are objections to these s……. staying in Putrajaya, Therefore just put with this unreasonable demand until the next GE and make sure this time around the warlords in Umno will no longer be the tenants of Putrajaya ! Let them have the word Allah, the non muslims will still grow and prosper without the right to use the word Allah !

  2. Dear Aliran, thank you for continuing to encourage some sense in the debate here. So difficult when politics get involved. Hope this resolves itself over time…keep up your good work wearing away at the stone of ignorance.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here