Has Anwar the numbers – or is it a bluff?

5
3343
Photograph: The Malaysian Insider

P Ramakrishan surveys the jittery reactions in government ranks ahead of Anwar’s audience with the Agong on Tuesday.

Anwar Ibrahim’s claim of having a “strong and formidable” majority to topple the Perikatan Nasional-led government has set tongues wagging. Attempts to play down this claim are very apparent in what is being said and how it is being said.

There are politicians who speak just for the sake of speaking. Not much thought or sense is reflected in what they say. Dr Mahathir Mohamad is no exception to this. We know he has no love or respect for Anwar, but that does not mean Anwar should not be treated honestly.

Anwar had claimed on 23 September 2020 he had a “strong and formidable” majority. He would not have laid claim to this majority if he did not have such a majority to support his claim. He wouldn’t risk his reputation for any dubious claim. He knows what the repercussions would be.

But politicians, being politicians, have disputed this claim and have ridiculed him. We know when politicians are driven by fear of impending doom, the first thing they would do is deny and ridicule their adversaries. That sort of reaction would pacify them!

Unsurprisingly, Mahathir fired the first salvo. “We will have to wait to see if this is another episode of making claims that cannot be substantiated,” he was quoted as saying (The Edge, Singapore).

Recalling Anwar’s former claim in 2008, Mahathir noted Anwar had made a similar declaration in 2008 – which did not materialise. While that is true, he wasn’t telling the whole truth – that is the problem with politicians.

We know what happened in September 2008 and how Pakatan Rakyat was prevented from taking over Putrajaya on 16 September 2008 (a move known as 916).

To frustrate Anwar and deny the majority that he supposedly had, 49 Barisan Nasional MPs were packed off to Taiwan on some silly excuse to study some agricultural projects. That was how they foiled Anwar’s attempt to bring about a change in government by bringing down Abdullah Badawi’s government. The BN effectively removed those who were likely to support Anwar.

That was why Anwar could not produce the majority he claimed he had in Parliament. If these MPs had been present in Parliament and, in spite of that, if Anwar had not been successful in taking over the government, then he could be rightly ridiculed.

But that wasn’t the case. It was out of fear of that possibility that, in desperation, the BN sent these 49 MPs out of the country, to keep them out of Anwar’s reach and save their own skin.

Not to be outdone by Mahathir, the Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin got into the picture, questioning Anwar’s claim of having a majority to form a new government. “But until today I myself also do not know (the number); his claim may or may not be true,” Muhyiddin said, when speaking at a Perikatan Nasional rally in Tambun on 25 September 2020.

Well, Mr PM, we also did not know whether you really had majority support when you were sworn in as prime minister on 1 March 2020. Not only did we not know the number you claimed you had then, but to date we still don’t know who really supported you. That remains a ‘state secret’, guarded and protected from public scrutiny.

On 29 February 2020, Mahathir had laid claim to 114 MPs supporting him. It was alleged you (Muhyiddin) also had 114 supporters backing you. But we have only 222 MPs in parliament – not 228! Mahathir had published the 114 names of MPs who allegedly supported him but you didn’t – which meant you only had 108 MPs behind you when you were sworn in.

Like a wolf pack, his ministers closed in lending support.

Science, Technology and Innovation Minister Khairy Jamaluddin tweeted just minutes after Anwar’s noon press conference on 23 September, saying the PN government was fine. “Just finished the cabinet meeting. Nothing is collapsing or falling,” he said.

Energy and Natural Resources Minister Shamsul Anuar Nasarah said on his Facebook page: “Remember the Sept 16, 2008, event? This time, it is another speculation…”

PN secretary-general Hamzah Zainudin described Anwar’s claim as nothing more than a political gimmick. He said it was merely the Port Dickson MP’s “September dream” of becoming prime minister.

All these minions tried to be dismissive of Anwar’s claim and the threat posed by him. It’s natural to assure yourselves that nothing is going to happen when you are faced with imminent danger. There is comfort in deluding yourselves.

I am reminded of an Arab proverb: “The dogs bark, but the caravan moves on.”

But strangely, Umno president Zahid Hamidi said, after Anwar’s 23 September press conference, he had received information that many Umno and BN members of Parliament had expressed support for opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim to form a new government.

“Umno and BN are not able to stop MPs supporting Anwar from meeting the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to make known his intention,” he said in a statement. “I was told that many Umno and BN MPs have voiced their support (for Anwar). I respect their decision.”

It is a known fact many MPs are not happy with Muhyiddin’s leadership. And Zahid Hamidi’s disclosure not only suggests but confirms that there may be many crossovers to Anwar’s side to make a change of government possible. With its razor-thin majority, the PN government is understandably jittery.

We will only know whether this so-claimed “strong and formidable” majority is fact or fiction on Tuesday after Anwar’s audience with the Agong. On Tuesday, Anwar’s fate will be sealed.

Many may wonder what will happen on Tuesday. If Anwar indeed possesses the so-claimed “strong and formidable” majority, the normal democratic convention would imply that Muhyiddin will have to step down as PM and Anwar will become the newly appointed PM – a dream come true at last!

Will this be the expected scenario? We will have to wait and see.

If Anwar indeed has very close to a two-thirds majority in Parliament, there is no reason to doubt he will be the ninth prime minister of Malaysia. Unlike Muhyiddin’s shaky and jittery government, Anwar’s government will be a very stable one, which makes it easier to serve the nation without having to look over the shoulders for backstabbers.

A stable government will be a welcome change and will be in a position to tackle the Covid-19 pandemic and address the economic woes of the nation. It will be mark the return of the Pakatan Harapan government, which was elected by Malaysians on 9 May 2018. This is what Malaysians want – the return of the government they voted for!

If for any reason, Anwar is not able to take the reins of government on Tuesday, all is not lost. Parliament is meeting on 2 November 2020. The PN government will be tabling Budget 2021 for adoption. If the Budget is defeated, then Muhyiddin’s government will surely fall. And nothing will stand in the way of Anwar becoming the Prime Minister.

This much-anticipated change of government will take place on Tuesday if all goes well. If not, Anwar will keep his date with destiny in November.

When he becomes PM, Anwar would have embodied the saying, “Most of the important things in the world have been accomplished by people who have kept on trying when there seemed to be no hope at all.”

Sign Aliran's 'Save our Democracy" petition
Sign Aliran's petition calling for a review of the decision to grant Riza Aziz a DNAA
Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Avatar
P Ramakrishan, the long-serving former president of Aliran who served three and a half decades on our executive committee, has been with Aliran since its inception in 1977. Now an ordinary Aliran member, he continues to highlight issues of public interest to a larger audience.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
5 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ronald
Ronald
15 Oct 2020 6.18pm

There is a lot of expectation among NGOs to place their hopes on Anwar to bring about change. Such hopes are understandable due to the years of Umno hegemony .The most importance question that is not ask
is who is he going to team up with in the quest for power.? One has too look at the current spat between bersatu and Umno for dominance to have some understanding of what Anwar could get into if he forms an alliance with Umno. What are the compromises that are going to be made?. Are there written consensus among all parties on the reforms to be undertaken? The Pakatan Harapan experience has clearly shown how race and religion could be easily exploited to topple an elected government .

loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
13 Oct 2020 5.23am

Thank you, Rama for this perspective on Anwar’s claim.
I have thought it foolish of Anwar to show his hand so openly but perhaps there’s a reason and rhyme to his action.
There is input that states that it is not in our country’s laws for the King to dismiss the backdoor PM, so Anwar’s show of strength if it materializes today, will indeed put more pressure on the backdoor PM.
Anwar, being a seasoned politician must know this.
Why is he making himself the butt of jokes circulating in social media if he does not have the numbers?

HHLim
HHLim
11 Oct 2020 10.13pm

Even if Anwar has the numbers or Muhyiddin’s budget is rejected, Anwar may still fail to become PM. Muhyiddin can advise the King to dissolve Parliament to have a snap election. True, by convention the King should not accede when another MP (i.e. Anwar) enjoys majority support in Parliament, but experience suggests there is no telling what will actually happen in Malaysia. And a fresh election is probably what UMNO is playing for.

Ng Kim Eng
Ng Kim Eng
11 Oct 2020 9.41pm

Most probably, DYMM Agong will revert to the executive power of Parliament to determine the vote of no confidence against the current sitting PM of this PN minority government even if DSAI can substantiate that he had the majority support of MPs to nominate him as the legitimate 9th. PM of Malaysia during his meeting with the Agong on 13th.Oct.2020

Venga
Venga
11 Oct 2020 8.59pm

I support Anwar for what he had been saying in the past for “reformasi” and I hope that he will revolutionize this country’s way of thinking and seek to make it an equal nation for all its citizens. Every opportunities are based on meritocracy and abilities not on race, or creed.

Last edited 10 days ago by Venga