Did Mahathir resign – or the cabinet resign?

We are in this disarray because one man, one man alone, through his foolhardiness, brought down a government

Photograph: zaid.my

Tommy Thomas, in his book My Story: Justice in the Wilderness, asserted that when Dr Mahathir Mohamad resigned as Prime Minister on 24 February 2020, it was an individual decision.

“It must be kept in mind that Tun’s resignation was personal, only as prime minister. The resignation was confined to that office, not the entire government.”

He further claimed that when prime ministers resign, their cabinets usually stay. In other words, since it was an individual’s decision to resign, the cabinet could not have been dissolved.

According to Muhammad Rafique Rashid Ali, a criminal lawyer from the Selangor Bar, when a prime minister resigns from the post, constitutionally the cabinet would be dissolved too.

Muhammad Rafique claimed that when Mahathir resigned, it was clear he had lost the majority in the Dewan Rakyat, especially after Bersatu left the Pakatan Harapan coalition together with several MPs from PKR.

These conflicting views raise the question whether Mahathir alone resigned or the cabinet resigned as well.

Perhaps, Article 43 (4) may throw some light.

43 (4) If the Prime Minister ceases to command the confidence of the majority of the members of the House of Representatives, then, unless at his request the Yang di- Pertuan Agong dissolves Parliament, the Prime Minister shall tender the resignation of the Cabinet.

According to the above provision, the prime minister only tenders the resignation of the cabinet when he has lost the confidence of the House or when the Yang di-Pertuan Agong dissolves Parliament at the request of the prime minister.

READ MORE:  What happened during the Budget vote?

It is a fact that Mahathir had not lost the confidence of Parliament. Parliament did not vote him out. Parliament was not in session for this to take place. Therefore, there was no loss of confidence requiring him to resign. And that is the fine point which defined the entire situation that unfolded.

In the event he was voted out, then he would be obliged to tender the resignation of the cabinet. But that situation was not present for him to tender the resignation of the cabinet. The prevailing circumstance did not warrant him to resign. There was no compelling reason whatsoever for him to embark on this course of action.

The other situation was also not present for him to resign. The Yang di-Pertuan Agong did not dissolve Parliament at the request of the prime minister. So there was no occasion for the prime minister to act and tender the resignation of the cabinet.

As such, the only conclusion is that Mahathir vacated his position on his own volition. He wasn’t forced out. He gave up his position voluntarily. He didn’t want to be a prime minister any more. It is as simple as that.

The government was not voted out. Therefore, the cabinet was not ousted.

In other words, the cabinet was intact, and the government had the majority to continue governing.

Under Article 43(4), the requirements mentioned for the PM to resign and submit the cabinet’s resignation were not met for this clause to come into effect.

When Mahathir presented his letter of resignation on 24 February at 1 pm, at that point in time, Pakatan Harapan had an unassailable majority in Parliament. If he had honourably passed the baton to Anwar as was unanimously agreed, the PH government would have continued to govern the country. It wouldn’t have collapsed. He wouldn’t have been in this present mess.

READ MORE:  Uproar in Parliament over Sabah MP's release from quarantine

Because he reneged on his word, and as there was a vacuum at that point in time, the ambitious, opportunistic politicians waiting in the wings for the right moment struck swiftly. Muhyiddin pulled out Bersatu from PH and Azmin Ali pulled out his gang from PKR.

It was Mahathir’s inexplicable and unforgiveable decision to resign unilaterally that caused the collapse of the duly elected people’s PH government.

We are in this disarray because one man, one man alone, through his foolhardiness, brought down a government that took 61 years to be elected by defeating the monolithic Barisan Nasional, when he chose to resign unilaterally.

His action dashed our hopes, crushed our dreams and ruined our country. He will not be forgiven for this betrayal of the peoples’ mandate and their trust.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
3 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Dr. SNaidu
Dr. SNaidu
10 Feb 2021 7.24pm

Convincing.Truths for common Rakyat?DrM blamed Azmin.In TV talk said lost majority.What drove him?Possibly, could n did not want to fulfill campaign promises-particularly those relating to n for the minority Ch,Indn,Org Asli,Sbh-Srwk natives for a Msia going forward.Many feel he, umno n the like want to keep nons as subjugated peoples as such- in turns of rights,equality, benefits?Formed Bersatu as M-only party.If the Ms are to benefit first, then others can too.Is this promise of Constn?Pls introspect to yr human core.Be EQUAL n serve all.Msia can grow in harmony as in Tunku’s time.Only if leaders, people think of the other first n oneself then, MSIA can blossom.Lessons are there for us to understand n act RIGHTLY.

Politi Scheiss
Politi Scheiss
6 Feb 2021 11.55am

What has happened has happened, so what is next?
There is a video going around WhatsApp of PN banners being printed supposedly in China and a belief that it is evidence of an upcoming snap GE15.
If PH is some PH parties team up with Mahathir again and/or UMNO. Then what.
What a political mess we are in.

loyal malaysian
loyal malaysian
6 Feb 2021 4.50am

“He will not be forgiven for this betrayal of the peoples’ mandate and their trust.” – my religion teaches me to live and let live, to forgive.
With this ex-dictator I can’t – I will add this curse : May he rot in hell for eternity for his betrayal.

Rama, I understand your good intentions to inform us as to what was the scenario when that evil man resigned as PM.
Yet, it is now all water under bridge – the backdoor PM and bloated govt. are firmly entrenched