Leaked UPSR papers: Don’t blame pupils for Education Ministry’s shambles

Muhyiddin Yassin

The Education Ministry should own up and take responsibility for a failed system and set up a high-level independent commission of inquiry to get to the bottom of this fiasco, fumes Leena Mohan.

The Education Ministry must take responsiblity

Since the time it was announced that the UPSR Science paper had leaked resulting in a postponement of the exam to 30 September, my daughter has been so distraught and upset. It is the first time I have seen her continuously sobbing and refusing to listen to any comforting words.

The effort put in to achieving peak performance during these three days of the UPSR exam has been tremendous for a 12-year-old child. As a parent, I have instilled in her that this public exam, her very first, is of utmost importance.

I know that she has taken this viewpoint seriously and has put in many hours of effort as part of her preparations. Her tears were of sheer frustration and disappointment at not being able to sit for the exam as scheduled after all the hard work. She expressed her anger at “the people who cheated and caused all this to happen”.

We have now got numerous public apologies from the Minister of Education and Minister of Education II. Apologies are not what I want. What I personally want is accountability. This incident is currently being investigated under the Official Secrets Act (OSA). I would like to know who had the audacity to sell this information and what action will be taken against these culprits.

But deep down, I know that this may be too high an expectation of a system in a shambles. There may be an investigation, and the culprits may never be found, much less charged in court. And the same vicious cycle will continue.

READ MORE:  Rape jokes aren't OK

This is the first major hurdle for these primary schoolchildren in terms of an education qualification, and it is messed up by the authorities. This situation is completely demoralising and disappointing. Now I am wondering, if a primary school public exam has been handled in this shabby manner, what can we expect of the management and handling of secondary school and tertiary exams?

Going by all the messages, phone calls and general public reaction, this incident has left a bad impression of the Malaysian education authorities in the minds of the young Primary Six students. It is a big let-down.

I hope this is a wake-up call – but there have already been so many wake-up calls in the past! – for the Malaysian Ministry of Education to get its act together, focus on educating Malaysians properly and weeding out corruption. We need a system that is based on excellence and meritocracy to progress.

Before we can even make sense of this issue, it has been announced that the English papers have also been leaked. There is also an indication that BM and Mathematics have also leaked out, which basically means the entire UPSR!

Here is what the Second Education Minister Idris Jusoh has to say: “Students have become too focused on just the examinations that they’re willing to cheat.”

What a ridiculous statement. Do not make baseless accusations that students are willing to cheat. The source of the leakage falls under Ministry jurisdiction and supervision.

Please take the blame, Minister. Own up and take responsibility for a failed system and set up a high-level independent commission of inquiry to get to the bottom of this fiasco.

READ MORE:  'Period spot checks' need to stop

Leena Mohan is an Aliran member based in Penang.

Correction: We apologise for the incorrect photo and caption put up earlier.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
1 Comment
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
KF Yong
KF Yong
12 Sep 2014 5.03am

Back in the 1975 when I was taking my ‘O’ levels, it was apparent that there were massive leaks in various subjects. One of the indications that there was a leak was when the test papers were in a different color other than plain white (e.g., tan or light blue). A different colored exam papers only indicated that the proctors had detected or had been notified of a leak. As a consequence, the test papers we received were the alternate tests that were available in the event of such a leak. I also remember coming to the exam hall to take my BM test when I noticed groups of my peers running around, huddled in layers frantically looking at something. When I was able to wade closer into the crowd of students, I noticed that the papers contained what looked like exam questions for the BM test. At that time I didn’t take it seriously, but when the papers were given out, I was shocked that the information i saw were the actual questions in the real test. I was depressed to realize that the rumors… Read more »