Revamp MACC to give it real independence


The MACC must be given real independence so that it can prosecute offenders without getting the nod from the Attorney General, writes Ronald Benjamin.


The Malaysian Corruption Perceptions index has worsened for the third consecutive year to 4.3 from 4.4. That the country’s ranking has dropped to 60th out of 183 countries from 56th out of 178 countries last year is not surprising.

According to Idris Jala of Pemandu, the introduction of a new survey conducted to measure the propensity of Malaysians paying bribes to parties outside Malaysia has dragged the overall performance down. The question that the Malaysian public would like to ask Idris Jala: Is our foundation of fighting corruption so weak that a certain new survey could suddenly bring us tumbling down? Is the propensity of Malaysians to bribe parties outside Malaysia not regarded as corruption in this country?

To rein in corruption effectively, the MACC has to be conscious of the truth that the rot of corruption always starts from the the top. The MACC has built a reputation of reining in the corrupt at the tail end, and such a reputation is repeatedly reinforced when it delays or does not take action against prominent ministers who use excessive unaccounted funds during general elections.

The grand scale of corruption in Malaysia is very much linked to the culture of money politics, and the MACC is weak in confronting this problem. The MACC has also failed to investigate the process of defence procurement and cabinet decisions awarding projects, guaranteed by public funds, to parties with a conflict of interest. The unanswered questions surrounding the Scorpene submarine deals and the latest feedlot issue provide examples of the MACC’s lethargy in taking prompt action.

READ MORE:  Six ways to achieve anti-corruption reforms in Malaysia

The lack of prompt action has resulted in the lost of millions of public funds which is reflected in the Auditor General’s Report. What makes things difficult in Malaysia are the extensive links among the government, political leaders and business, and this requires a competent MACC that is able to rein in corruption at the roots.

The MACC must be given real independence so that it can prosecute offenders without getting the nod from the Attorney General. MACC leaders must be answerable to parliamentary inquiries. The current advisers of the MACC should resign as they are basically as ineffective as the former advisers because the environment and culture that prevent bold action remain.

Expecting great results while doing the same thing brings repeated failure – something that Idris Jala should reflect upon instead of blaming the new survey.

Ronald Benjamin, an Aliran member, is a human resources practitioner based in Ipoh.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
najib manaukau
25 Dec 2011 8.02am

You can steal millions of ringgits and get sentenced to one year in prison and if you steal a few boxes of shampoo worth no more than just a few hundred ringgits you will then get two years in prison. Are these the kind of deterrents in boleh land ! No wonder (someone allegedly) dared to steal million for his sons and family and billions of ringgit for himself for he knows dam well he will get away from them as there is really no MACC or even an anti corruption department in Malaysia. As long as the corruptions are done by the deceitful and corrupted morons. I must further add that there is no anti corruption in Malaysia for the deceitful and corrupted morons especially so if it is done in the name of helping the Malays and implementing the NEP (Never Enough Policy). That is why (this someone) is fighting tooth and nail to be known as a Malay or at best an Umno made Malay to do just that. He has also hijacked the NEP which was set up to help the poor… Read more »

Jack Daniel
24 Dec 2011 11.08am

Khir Toto is the tip of the iceberg !!

najib manaukau
24 Dec 2011 7.27am

What will then happen to all the morons from Umno if MACC became independent ? Will there be anyone left in deceitful and corrupted Umno morons when even with only a minimum numbers of them are indicted, for show I might add. Any wonder why Malaysia is so very badly rated and the sure way to be rated lower .

charlie chan
23 Dec 2011 11.53pm

its show time now- pictures of MACC in action all over the MSM- printed media???are they really serious to fight corruption??? awang said- i accept deposits n monies but its not corruption – its donation lah>>>kak shah said- which omno leader have no problem???malaysians- will you buy the story??? where is the beef lah???