Bersih rally, English riots: A crucial difference


Bersih was a demonstration of hope while the English riots were the converse – a demonstration of hopelessness, notes our special correspondent.

Brixton Road - Photograph:

Yes, the ministers and their hangers-on will point to the English (it’s not just London) riots as a hopelessly stupid reason for the crackdown on Bersih.

What they miss is the fundamental difference between Bersih and the English riots. Bersih was a demonstration of hope — and hope, as some wise person once said, is a memory of the future.

The English riots were the converse – a demonstration of hopelessness, and the absence of futures worth contemplating, made worse by the expenditure cuts to satisfy the “market”, namely, the rich. It was all right to incur huge deficits to bail out the fat cats, who – as was clear from the reaction to the Federal Open Market Committee of the Federal Reserve last night – want more bailouts for themselves. But when it comes to cuts, it is cut taxes, and cut social expenditure. As Joseph Stiglitz put it, we are in a regime of the 1 per cent, for the 1 per cent, by the 1 per cent (at the top of the income distribution).

However, let’s not beguile ourselves. Inequality in England exploded in these past three decades, starting with Thatcher’s (infamous) declaration that there is no such thing as society.

Over here, these past three decades, concentrated on righting inter-ethnic inequality, were also at the same time creating widening inequalities overall. Today, we have an unemployment rate of around 18 per cent amongst our young people aged 15-19, up from around 8 per cent in the 1990s; amongst 20-24, it’s a still high 9 per cent, not as bad as in England or in the US, but still bad.

Meanwhile, although technically measured inequality does not appear to have worsened – whereas it clearly has in England – the absolute income gap between the top and bottom has widened.

At the same time, we are increasingly or daily reminded on television and in the media that we should define ourselves as consumers: we are what we consume, so that those without the wherewithal to consume become “losers”, “zeroes”, “nothings” or whatever names the relatively privileged arrogantly and ignorantly choose to call them.

And, as everywhere, the rulers look to blame “social media” when it affects them. Fascinating, isn’t it? When it happens in Egypt, “social media” is celebrated in the west and castigated by Egypt’s rulers, but when it happens in England “social media” is castigated by England’s rulers, while those in the ex-colonies might even join in the blind condemnation of the riots. The old colonial mindset remains with us, but even more, the old class divisions and the invisibility of the poor and lower classes remain, until they erupt.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nooraini Mydin
Nooraini Mydin
14 Aug 2011 10.29am

It is not wrong for the Malaysian government to point to the riots in London and other English cities and say “we don’t want this in our country.” Regardless of what the tourist brochures misht say, the people of Malaysia are not living in such perfect harmony. Just open any blog and you see expletives used by one race against another. These people have lost all respect for each other. That makes them the same as the looters in England who had no regard for people or law and order. The BERSIH rally might have laudable but the organisers scored an own goal by breaking the law and encouraging Malaysians to participate in an ILLEGAL rally. I don’t want to see Malaysia destroyed like the rioters destroyed London and other English cities. I particularly don’t want to see a race riot which will cause damage that will take generations to repair. I pride myself as one who loves the diversity of Malaysia; yet when I read the racist remarks on the internet, I become a racist in the interest of defending the good name of my… Read more »

14 Aug 2011 7.27pm
Reply to  Nooraini Mydin

Well written Nooraini but you made a mistake. What law did the Bersih 2.0 rally organizers break? The one that UMNO’s Home Minister and police made up? That yellow colored t-shirts with the word Bersih 2.0 is illegal? When was that law gazzeted anyway?

13 Aug 2011 8.58am

This is typical of deceitful and corrupted Umno that would use a bad example to fustily their actions. Also two wrongs don’t make one right, needless to say it is something these deceitful and corrupted morons from Umno do not know and will never.
The only to stop the on going arguments and deceits of Umno is to come out and cast your vote in the coming GE to kick these good for nothing morons out of their gravy trains, ivory towers and last of all their continuous deceits once and for all.
They don’t know how to listen to reasons and don’t know how to change for good so just kick (them) … out !