10 ways MCA has failed Malaysians

15

In an open letter, Tota says MCA leaders are more interested in position-sharing than power-sharing.

For more than 50 years, many Chinese Malaysians were duped into blindly giving their vote to the MCA. This support enabled the Alliance/BN to control Parliament with a two-thirds majority and successfully undermine democracy.

The MCA has always claimed to be the protector and saviour of the Chinese. Let us look at MCA’s record. If MCA leaders and supporters suffer from amnesia, this ought to refresh their memories.

1. The MCA leadership was implicated in a scandal involving 600,000 Chinese Malaysian depositors who placed hundreds of millions of ringgit of savings in 24 deposit-taking cooperatives. Many of the depositors were left in a lurch when the scheme collapsed.

2. The MCA’s Multi-Purpose Society in which many Chinese invested their money was a total failure, and then MCA president Tan Koon Swan went to prison for criminal breach of trust.

3. The MCA joined Umno to deny participatory democracy by cancelling local council elections. Many town and city council dwellers are Chinese Malaysians and the MCA feared that control of town and city councils would fall into the hands of the Opposition, especially DAP. It was despicable that MCA put self-interest above national interest and democracy. .

5. The MCA supported Umno when the provision of a 1:2 rural-to-urban weighting in constituency boundary changes was amended in 1973, thus leading to an even more lop-sided electoral system with malapportionment of voters. Some urban parliamentary constituencies have over 130,000 voters while rural constituencies have 30,000 voters. This makes the principle of one person, one vote a joke. With such serious gerrymanderng, BN is able to win 60% of the parliamentary seats while getting less than 50% of the popular vote.

READ MORE:  Throwing open the doors to inclusive politics... not

6. With the MCA’s connivance and collusion, many of the sacrosanct provisions in the Constitution have been mutilated. Civil rights and liberties were destroyed when oppressive and repressive laws such as the Internal Security Act, the Official Secrets Act, the Sedition Act, the Printing Presses and Publications Act and the Universities and University Colleges Act were passed.

Until recently the deputy minister of education has been from the MCA, and yet the Ministry of Education was permitted to become the most racist in the country. There are 25-odd public universities; all vice-chancellors are Malays. There are four deputy vice-chancellors in each university; usually just one is non-Malay. Most of the deans in the universities are Malays. All 13 directors of education and deputies are Malays. If, as the MCA claims, there is power-sharing, such a situation would not arise.

MCA leaders should get it into their heads that there is no power-sharing with Umno. It is merely position sharing. If there is power-sharing, what was the necessity for the MCA, the MIC and Gerakan to send a memorandum to Abdullah Badawi. When Umno took offence, the senders of the memorandum retracted the memorandum. I challenge the MCA to put the memorandum, which is not under the Official Secrets Act, in the public domain and let people judge the legitimacy of their demands.

7. Umno has successfully emasculated the MCA and made its leaders political eunuchs. Umno is no respecter of the Constitution, rule of law and agreements. Our Merdeka Constitution, which in fact is the social contract, has been shredded. Look how Umno-dominated BN, supported by the MCA, has eroded the Cobbold Commission’s 20-point Sabah Agreement and the 18-point Sarawak Agreement.

READ MORE:  When MCA is left at sea

8. The MCA is now the appointed critic of the DAP. The MCA frequently criticised the DAP for working with Pas in the Pakatan-led Selangor government, thereby supporting hudud, it claimed. But it was Umno which allowed – behind the MCA’s back – a Pas motion on the hudud agenda to move up the parliamentary order paper.

9. The MCA president called the DAP “the most unprincipled politcal party in the world”. How principled is the MCA? After the thrashing they got at the 1969 general election, Tan Siew Sin and his team withdrew from the government – only to crawl back because the pay and perks were too good to forego. Very principled indeed!

10. The MCA repeated its shameful performance after its thrashing in the 2008 election – leaving the government temporarily and shamelessly crawling back.

I urge Chinese Malaysians to see the MCA for what it really is – imbecile, boot lickers of Umno – not their protecter.

Show Umno that we are a dignified people and bribery will not win our votes.

Tota is the pseudonym of an occasional contributor to our Thinking Allowed section.

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
15 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Nair
Nair
5 May 2018 6.00pm

We dont need all the Race Base Party like UMNO,MCA,MIC………….
That system is Colonial system to rule & divide.
What we need is a Leader without Corruption & Racialism.
1 Malaysia 1 Rakyat is Bangsa Malaysia.

DrKatherine Poh
5 May 2018 2.18pm

What did MCA do when we were attacked “Apa Cina magi” and “cina babi” .. this shows the party do not have the Chinese at heart!

Albert Low
5 May 2018 11.36am

MCA party don’t help the Chinese in Malaysia .We must not vote or trust MCA .

Johndoe.
Johndoe.
4 May 2018 8.45pm

No diff with
MIC lah.

Joshua Lim
4 May 2018 8.36pm

10 ways are too few…

Roy Ernest Lim
4 May 2018 7.12pm

I can name at least 20 ways

Noor Azlen
4 May 2018 1.08pm

U mean Party Party lain ok tak fail?

Michael Tan Eng Hong
4 May 2018 12.20pm

There are more than 10 ways!!!

Wengseng Chan
4 May 2018 10.02am

Only 10?

Lim Oon Tin
4 May 2018 9.30am

WHAT??? ONLY 10???
BUT AS A WALKING DEAD PARTY?? ONE IS ENOUGH.
THEY DO NOT REPRESENT THE CHINESE !! ONLY THEMSELVES?? CANNOT RELY
ON THEM IIN CRISIS??
EXAMPLE? JAMAL JAMBAN RED SHIRTS RIOTS?? IN CHINA TOWN?? NONE???
NO ONE OF THEM WERE THERE AT GROUND ZERO???
ONLY CHINA EMBASSADOR WAS THERE!! HOPELESS USELESS ONLY REPRESENT
AND ENRICHING THEMSELVES WITH CONTRACTS AND OOF COURSE… !!??

Foo Wah Chau
4 May 2018 9.01am

… masih nak sokong penyamun perintah negara lagi. Maruah cina telah dimalukan olehnya. Jangan hanya fikir kepentingan diri saja sanggup gadaikan negara pada penyamun

Shan
Shan
5 May 2018 1.22pm
Reply to  Foo Wah Chau

Bakal PM pakatanlah yang jadi penyamun dulu.lagi nak jadikan PM.ada beza ke?semua dasar Mahathir yang buat..

Shan
Shan
5 May 2018 1.31pm
Reply to  Foo Wah Chau

Orang yang kau nak lantik jadi PM pun sama jugak.Mahathir, Anwar semua dulu adalah orang yang mentadbir kerajaan.Mahathir paling lama..lagi nak lantik orang sama..2 x 5…

Mathew Mathen
4 May 2018 8.58am

Only 10 ?

HoGiam Hglgsb
4 May 2018 8.50am

Not just 10 ways Mca is a failure Mca take care of its own pocket all they think is how to fill their pocket with dedak n more dedak