Sad outburst by Chandra

2

chandraMany people have been calling up the Aliran office to express their outrage about Dr Chandra Muzaffar’s critical comments of Anwar Ibrahim and the PKR which have been given widespread coverage in the mainstream media. These people have enquired about Aliran’s views on the matter, since Chandra was referred to as the founder of Aliran.

In this regard, we wish to clarify that Chandra has not been an active member since 1991, when he stepped down as president and later went on to establish JUST.

More importantly, we wish to state that Aliran does not share Chandra’s recent remarks vis-à-vis Anwar Ibrahim and PKR. Neither do we share his views that the BN despite its flaws is a better choice. Indeed, we are rather perturbed by his apparently emotional outburst.

In contrast to Chandra’s position, Aliran calls upon fellow Malaysians to vote in a stronger Opposition. It is important to deny the Barisan Nasional a two-thirds majority which has allowed them to amend the Constitution at will and ride
roughshod over dissenting views. A stronger Opposition will help to consolidate Malaysia’s fledging democracy. Too often, we have sacrificed democracy to pursue  development – and that too, a model of development which has
concentrated wealth in the hands of a minority.

To reiterate, Aliran stands for sustainable people-centred development and democracy for all. We have asserted this position in the latest two issues of Aliran Monthly, which have focused on the 2008 elections.

Chandra’s remarks as reported in the mainstream media appear to emphasise that Anwar Ibrahim is not a leader who can be trusted. Apparently, money politics is also prevalent in the PKR. If this is true, it is cause for concern because the implication is that the money politics disease has spread from the BN to the PKR! From our knowledge, money politics is indeed widespread within the ruling BN parties. It is odd, therefore, that Chandra should be so concerned about the problem of money politics in PKR per se. At the same time, he has not said much of late about the money politics which has always been associated with the BN.

Chandra also has highlighted the supposedly racial scare tactics used by PKR during the Lunas by-election. For us, such dirty tricks have been resorted to by all parties especially the BN. Again, all forms of racial baiting by all parties should be condemned.

The most disturbing aspect of this episode is how Dr Chandra Muzaffar has wittingly or unwittingly lent himself to be a part of the BN propaganda machine. It is sad that a prominent intellectual and long-time activist of his standing has such a blinkered view of the issue at hand. We wonder why he did not make these alleged goings-on public earlier and follow up on them conclusively given his public stance on integrity and accountability.

Why only now?

P Ramakrishnan, President

Francis Loh, Hon Secretary

Mustafa K Anuar, Asst Hon Secretary

Anil Netto, Hon Treasurer

On behalf of the Aliran Executive Committee

5 March 2008

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Avatar
P Ramakrishan, the long-serving former president of Aliran who served three and a half decades on our executive committee, has been with Aliran since its inception in 1977. Now an ordinary Aliran member, he continues to highlight issues of public interest to a larger audience.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
K. Haridas
K. Haridas
18 Mar 2013 8.19am

When you are blinded by bitterness for an individual than that colours your judgment and perspectives. Chandra has a great mind but of late this mind is clouded by bitterness and the result is the warped views that he now shares. He does not want change and cannot even understand that Malaysian politics is doomed if its continues to be ethnic based.The challenges facing Malaysia presently cannot be solved at the level of race and ethnicity. We have to be fair to all and this can only be achieved by calls for social justice, fairness and equality where all get to enjoy the Malaysian sun. The same can also be said of Tunku Aziz following his split from DAP. A sad state for the so called public intellectuals who are not able to rise above and articulate ‘what is right’ – a transcending view. K. Haridas.

V.Chandrasekaran
V.Chandrasekaran
22 Jan 2012 4.47am

Even wise men can be clouded by circumstances, so it seems. While one can accept that great thinkers have faltered in times of tribulations, it is still a wonder, how a person of his magnitude, blessed with sound and critical thinking like Chandra, can have his wisdom clouded. If politics, and shrewd politicians, can detract even sound minds like Chandra, then one should start doubting all self-proclaimed activists who shout their hearts out opposing oppressive political systems at one juncture and bow down to the might of the powers-be and the powerful the next. It seems one ought to be careful not of cunning politicians but powerful personalities who change their colours like chameleons according to the situation and environment.