Proposed ‘fake news’ bill is a threat to freedom of expression

18
1 view

We, the undersigned civil society organisations, are deeply concerned about plans to table a bill to address ‘fake news’ in Parliament next week.

The bill, if adopted, will add to a range of repressive laws that have been used to violate the right to freedom of expression and undermine media freedom in Malaysia. We urge the government to drop the proposed bill, which we believe is yet another attempt to stifle debate and criminalise those who speak out against corruption and human rights violations.

In the context of the impending general elections, we are concerned that the ‘fake news’ bill could be used as a dragnet to criminalise reporting on government misconduct, the expression of critical opinions, and the speech of the political opposition.

Compounding these concerns are the inadequate constitutional protections for freedom of expression in Malaysia. Malaysian authorities have selectively prosecuted Malaysian opposition politicians, human rights defenders and journalists under existing laws for exercising their right to freedom of expression.

The proposed bill was agreed on this week by the cabinet and will be put before Parliament next week, ahead of the coming general election to be held by August 2018. The government has said the bill is needed to defend “national security and public order” and has stated it will not affect freedom of expression, as protected by the Malaysian Constitution.

However, the notion of ‘fake news’ is extremely vague and open to arbitrary interpretation, and legislation criminalising or otherwise censoring ‘fake news’ will likely give the authorities extensive powers to determine what information the public may access.

READ MORE:  When the government fears the people, it suppresses freedom of speech

Laws presented as attempts to protect the public from misinformation can often act as tools for governments to restrict the presentation of dissenting views or ideas, and ultimately violate the right to freedom of expression.

While Malaysia has failed to ratify the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which protects the right to freedom of expression, international standards require that restrictions on freedom of expression on the supposed basis of national security or public order must be clearly set out in law, and necessary and proportionate to protect those aims.

UN and regional special rapporteurs have made clear in a joint declaration on freedom of expression and ‘fake news’ that broad restrictions on ‘fake news’ do not pass that test, stating, “General prohibitions on the dissemination of information based on vague and ambiguous ideas, including ‘false news’ or ‘non-objective information’, are incompatible with international standards for restrictions on freedom of expression.”

In Malaysia, the passage of a ‘fake news’ law would likely deepen the already existing restrictive environment for expression and further suppress public discourse and legitimate criticism of public officials and other powerful individuals.

Recently the Ministry of Communications and Multimedia warned of “stern actions” against those “propagating and spreading fake news” in relation to the 1MDB scandal, in which Prime Minister Najib Razak is implicated.

Deputy Communications and Multimedia Minister Jailani Johari has further stated that 1MDB-related information from sources other than Malaysian government authorities will be considered ‘fake news’, essentially establishing government authorities as the final arbiter of truthfulness.

READ MORE:  Home minister’s statement is worrying sign for future of freedom of expression

This issue is further compounded by a lack of transparency resulting from the Malaysian government’s abuse of the Official Secrets Act and the lack of comprehensive access to information legislation. The authorities have previously cracked down on those reporting on the 1MDB scandal using the repressive Communications and Multimedia Act.

We are also concerned by the government’s lack of transparency regarding the bill. The government has excluded key stakeholders from among civil society and the human rights community from consultations regarding the bill and has not published the proposed legislation. Any efforts to genuinely tackle the spread of misinformation online must be approached in a transparent, consultative manner and avoid broad criminal restrictions on speech.

Many of the existing laws used to restrict freedom of expression in Malaysia — including provisions relating to false information, slander and malicious content online and offline — are overly broad and restrictive. We urge the Malaysian government to prioritise a review of these laws and reforms to bring them in line with international human rights standards.

We call upon the government to immediately withdraw the proposed ‘fake news’ bill and ensure any future legislative proposals that have implications for the media or civil society are developed in full consultation with all stakeholders.

It is crucial that the government takes steps to develop an enabling environment for freedom of expression in line with international standards ahead of upcoming elections, and end its use of flawed legislation to restrict free speech. ‘Fake news’ may be an increasingly popular buzzword, but it cannot serve as an excuse for the government to violate freedom of expression and censor criticism.

READ MORE:  The ban-demic is back – or was it never gone?

Signed:

Article 19
Aliran Kesedaran Negara (Aliran)
Center to Combat Corruption and Cronyism (C4 Center)
Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ)
Civicus – World Alliance for Citizen Participation
Diversity
Pergerakan Tenaga Akademik Malaysia (Gerak)
Justice for Sisters
Pelangi – Campaign for Equality and Human Rights Initiative
Persatuan Kesedaran Komuniti Selangor
Projek Dialog
Sinar Project
Suara Rakyat Malaysia (Suaram)

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
18 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Frank Meeng
24 Mar 2018 12.22pm

Democracy….” My way ” style… is the beginning of Dictactorship ruling with an “Iron Fist”…

Lim Heng Hin
24 Mar 2018 10.20am

Normal ordinary people on the street are intelligent enough to smell a “ fake news” and they are adequate laws in the country to haul them to court if the news is fake. So, what is a “fake news” when you don’t have the gall to charge them in court? Come on, grow a brain and don’t hide in stupidity and take the easy way out by suppressing the truth. It only shows your desperation and you have everything to hide.
“Quo Vadis Malaysia!”

Thurai Singam Chandra Sehkaran
24 Mar 2018 8.11am

How could fake news effect someone or the government?
Isn’t there defamation acts still in enforcement?
If something is fake news, then why it should be concerned?
May be some business men may be effected by fake news, but what will effect the government?
Isn’t there verification procedures still practiced in government policies?
What is different between fake news, personal views, debating matters, discussion matters, hypothesis, circulating topics, RUMORS, GOSSIPS, UNKNOWN FACTS, UNPROVEN FACTS & UNVERIFIED NEWS
Fake news only to be applied on ministers, government staffs, mp’s, adun’s, political parties speeches in public && recorded medias, mcmc registered news channels & portals. NOT ON COMMON MAN…let say someone shered an unverified news from foreign, Im sharing it to several friends for verification, especially related to politics… Isn’t that unfair policies of ruling political parties against opposition…

Sezhian Vescara
24 Mar 2018 12.41am

Is there anymore freedom here?

Roy Yuen
24 Mar 2018 12.49am

The Govt. Should Come Clean. Abt Their Own Propaganda First.!!!

Mei Mey
23 Mar 2018 9.15pm

Fake human being..

Hassan Wahab
23 Mar 2018 11.50pm
Reply to  Mei Mey

No…no..no…fake man …..la…la….la…..

Frank Meeng
24 Mar 2018 12.18pm
Reply to  Mei Mey

Yet to be researched thoroughly…still catogerised as ” Unknown Species”…

Lim Heng Hin
24 Mar 2018 2.04pm
Reply to  Mei Mey

Haha…. only fake humans with fake news, I suppose….🤣🤣🤣👌🏿

Ronnie Maddog
23 Mar 2018 7.34pm

What is the definition of “fake news”? And shud it be tabled and motion passed, it shud adhere to both sides of the coin.

Pernelle Lim
23 Mar 2018 8.25pm
Reply to  Ronnie Maddog

1mdb,, anything to do with 1mdb is fake news,

Lim Oon Tin
23 Mar 2018 7.17pm

Dictatorship BN. !!

Lim Oon Tin
23 Mar 2018 7.17pm

Contravenes the CONSTITUTION ??

Barney Muthu
23 Mar 2018 7.11pm

But it will protect crooked leaders in the government.

Ann Marie Moohan-Sidhu
23 Mar 2018 6.59pm

Holding on to power by any means

Paul Leong
23 Mar 2018 7.12pm

That’s what they are doing

Lau Chengkeat
23 Mar 2018 6.53pm

Kia su!

Gunasekaran Balasundaram
23 Mar 2018 6.47pm

Oppressive , suppressive and repressive BN.