Shopping therapy won’t solve MH370 crisis


We need to stop the government from going on a random ‘syok sendiri’ shopping spree for big toys, with the crisis as an excuse, says Steven Sim.


Have you heard? The government is now preparing to go on a multi-million (maybe even billion) ringgit shopping spree for defence equipment following the MH370 crisis.

See the news for yourself here.

Previously, I wrote that 100 days had passed since MH370 went missing, and yet, everything about it is still shrouded in deep mystery. There are so many conspiracy theories on the internet that we do not know what to believe anymore.

What my colleagues and I have been pushing since day one is a parliamentary committee to investigate what happened. I have also called for an SOP audit, post-mortem and white paper by the government.

But nothing till now. Even my question on this issue in Parliament was rejected under the pretext of it being a “secret”.

Defence is a mulit-billion ringgit industry even for a small country like Malaysia. The defence budget for Malaysia has been on the rise every year from RM13.82bn in 2011 to RM16.1bn in 2014.

My colleague Choong Wah, Senior Fellow of Refsa, a defence expert, estimated that about RM70bn was spent on defence since the First Malaysia Plan (1966) until now.

READ MORE:  NGOs: Recognise unions; don't deny freedom of association.

That much money, along with a lack of accountability, means a huge risk for hanky-panky.

It is no wonder then, that in the 2013 Defence Anti-Corruption Index, Malaysia is ranked in band D, receiving a D-, meaning, a lower performance country among high-risk countries in defence-related corruption. The report on Malaysia was centred on the lack of accountability and transparency especially in the area of defence budgets, finance, operations and procurement.

The “crisis-as-excuse shopping” is a good example why Malaysia is ranked D-.

We need to stop the government from going on a random ‘syok sendiri’ shopping spree for big toys, with the crisis as an excuse. My colleague and I have called for the formation of a bipartisan Defence Account Parliamentary Committee which includes civilian military experts to provide oversight on defence-related spending.

This is our full statement. Please share it with more people to create awareness.

The so-called ‘Transparency Minister’, Paul Low, must realise that transparency is not merely about capturing a malpractice in the audit report after it has occurred.

But rather a transparency checkpoint must be placed at the beginning of any government process.

(And having a thick audit report doesn’t make us better than Singapore, please Minister Low. If anything it shows that our government abuses are rampant and serious).

Steven Sim is the member of parliament for Bukit Mertajam.

(Visited 20 times, 1 visits today)
Thanks for dropping by! You are one of an increasing number of readers looking up Aliran for independent analyses and views. We work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to continue the struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. So would you consider making a donation to keep us going - or why not become an Aliran member or subscribe to our FREE newsletters.


  1. The shopping spree by the Umno schmucks is only an excuse for them to enrich themselves with inflated bills and charges. It is for these reasons Malaysia never, for sometimes after the search was started by foreign countries. A good example, why is Malaysia only in the last few days offering to use the submarine it always has. When the submarine was always at their disposable and why wasn’t it used from the beginning of the search ? In fact Malaysia did not offer to help (much), well not at least for the first week or two and it did it was just a token of their effort to help in the search of MH370.

    But it is now coming up with the submarine and million or billion of dollars worth of contract to help in the search of MH370. Why, only now ? Even fools … know Malaysia is able to decide what they can do and where they can spend the millions or billions ? This undoubtedly would lead to the question how much the spending , as usual, will end up in the pockets of the decision makers ! On top of this issue it is also diverting the attention of the people from the many other urgent issues Malaysia have, finally will Malaysia be able to locate MH370, it is literally worse than looking for a needle in the hay stack not to mention it is looking for a needle in the oceans. What a … shamble this country is getting itself into ! But one thing for sure the Umno schmucks are now able to avail themselves … to millions or billions of ringgit (of defence spending)!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here