Granting of licence to Lynas: A ‘grand historical betrayal of trust’

4
The anti-Lynas movement

Save Malaysia Stop Lynas has noted with great disappointment and regret that the AELB has granted Lynas a renewal of the TOL (renamed FOSL-Full Operating Stage Licence) for another two years.

The anti-Lynas movement
The anti-Lynas movement

AELB director-general Hamrah Mohd Ali confirmed today that the board agreed at a meeting last week to issue a two-year FOSL to Lynas. Hamrah said the decision was based on Lynas having fully complied with the conditions set by AELB during its TOL operating stage.

We wish to remind the AELB Director General Hamrah Mohd Ali that Lynas has failed to fulfil ALL the conditions set by the AELB when the TOL was issued!

Here are the conditions attached to the TOL :

  •  Lynas to submit all details of a Permanent Disposal facility (PDF);
  •  Lynas to submit a plan and location details for the PDF, regardless of the outcome of research and development into commercialisation, recycling and reuse of solid residue materials;
  • Lynas’ plan and the location of the PDF to be submitted and approved within 10 months from the date of issuance of the TOL;
  • Lynas to establish a fund of USD$50m as a financial guarantee;
  • The AELB reserves the right to appoint an independent consultant to evaluate compliance with the standards and regulations that have been set, the cost of which will be borne by Lynas;
  • Lynas must submit to the Board a method to immobilise radioactive elements in the residue to be disposed in the event excessive residue is stored in the Residue Storage Facility (RSF). The method is also to trap radioactive elements from being released into the environment. The immobilisation methods are to be approved by the Board and would be made part of the licence conditions; and
  • With regard to the radioactive residue disposal, Lynas must submit an Emergency Response Plan (ERP) to control the release of dust from the residue into the air and the environment. The ERP has to be endorsed by the Board. The Plan is necessary in the event the water sprinkler system fails. The response plan should include a contingency measure to provide an alternative water source on standby at all times. The endorsed ERP will be made part of the licence conditions.

These are the facts regarding the claim that Lynas has fulfilled ALL the conditions in the TOL:

  • It has been openly admitted both in the Parliament and subsequent public statements and remarks to the media by you and the former DG, Dato Raja Abdul Aziz, that Lynas has yet to identify the location for the PDF (Condition 2)!
  • failed to submit the location and plans for the PDF and get it approved within the 10-month period of its operations (Condition 3). The AELB has either been blind to these facts or chose to disregard the facts presented in our memorandum to them on 14 Auugust 2014.
  • As the regulating authority on the Lynas Advance Materials Plant (Lamp), it has failed to invite independent consultant(s) as provided for under the TOL to do a thorough evaluation of Lamp’s operations throughout the duration of its licence (Conditions 5)!

With such undeniable failures on the part of Lynas to fulfil the conditions of the TOL as stated above, the AELB has decided to renew Lynas’ TOL for another two years! This is a grand historical betrayal of trust and credibility of the AELB and it is wholly irresponsible and totally despicable!

The AELB and the Board have failed the people and all future generations of Malaysia yet again.

SMSL hereby call upon the Mosti Minister and the Government of Malaysia to retire the DG and dismiss the entire Board that is responsible for making such a decision that is totally untenable with the facts of the case!

Save Malaysia Stop Lynas
3 September 2014

Thanks for dropping by! The views expressed in Aliran's media statements and the NGO statements we have endorsed reflect Aliran's official stand. Views and opinions expressed in other pieces published here do not necessarily reflect Aliran's official position.

Our voluntary writers work hard to keep these articles free for all to read. But we do need funds to support our struggle for Justice, Freedom and Solidarity. To maintain our editorial independence, we do not carry any advertisements; nor do we accept funding from dubious sources. If everyone reading this was to make a donation, our fundraising target for the year would be achieved within a week. So please consider making a donation to Persatuan Aliran Kesedaran Negara, CIMB Bank account number 8004240948.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bob
Bob
10 Sep 2014 9.11pm

Unfortunately it is ignorant people who believe such nonsense. Link to environmental monitoring data from third party independent consultants. This is publicly available information.
https://www.lynascorp.com/Announcements/2013/Media%20Release_Environmental%20monitoring%2001082013%201242685.pdf

Lim Teck Hing
Lim Teck Hing
10 Sep 2014 5.07pm

Did AELB lied when they reported that Lynas has fulfilled all the conditions? If not, they must be brought to court!

If Lynas did indeed fulfilled all conditions, where is the permanent disposal facility (PDF) located? Why the hush-hush?

charleskiwi
9 Sep 2014 8.02am

Now you know why Australia is so ‘keen’ to help in the search of MH370 in every way, even though Australia themselves are trimming down their own latest budgets despite protest from their own people. They are doing more than Malaysia themselves in the search of MH30. Australia is coming up with tens of millions to help in the search of MH370, the success of locating the remains of MAS has absolutely nothing to do with them. Believe me this is not the end of the story, a lot more to come, like the refugees seeking refuge in Australia especially when their closest neigbour, Indonesia only until very recently, was not in good term with them as a result of the spying scandals. They have to find an ‘idiot’ of a country in the nearby region to accept them. These refugees are costing Australia billions of dollars over the last few decades, not to mention the endless other problems that come with them. For these reason plus any outlets, like Lynas that they do not even want it built in their own backyards. They found Malaysia… Read more »

Lim Teck Hing
Lim Teck Hing
10 Sep 2014 5.14pm
Reply to  charleskiwi

To be fair, Australia is not to be blamed for Lynas which is a private entity. The question should be directed to the Malaysian government in granting Lynas to operate here given the negative publicity of the project.